Search:  

 
 
   News
newer
story category In Flight Cell Phone Ban May Be Lifted
FCC continues official inquiry into possibility
(old news - 06:37PM Tuesday Feb 15 2005)
tags: fcc · wireless
The FCC today officially began considering (see pdf press release) lifting the in-flight cell phone ban. Specifically, they're considering allowing the use of wireless devices "so long as the device operates at its lowest power setting under control of a "pico cell" (a mini-coverage area) located on the aircraft."

Related:
  1. FCC To Shorten Landline Port Window
  2. Exploring FCC Warrantless Home Searches
  3. FCC To Investigate Exclusive Handset Deals
  4. WSJ: AT&T Is Dying
  5. FCC To Probe AT&T, Verizon Wireless
  6. FCC Votes To Investigate Wireless Industry
  7. Apple Lied To FCC About Blocking Google Voice
  8. FCC Lusts After TV Industry Spectrum
Forums » In Flight Cell Phone Ban May Be Lifted
view: topics flat text 
Post a:
Aleck79

join:2003-07-23
College Station, TX

great, cell phones replacing the crying baby

I can just see it now, no more jokes about the crying baby on the airline, its going to be the asshole on the cell phone :x

91439306
15,000 Watts of Bass Power

join:2002-10-16
New Milford, CT

Re: great, cell phones replacing the crying baby

Just consider what it's like to get an $82 bill for a 5-minute phone call from GTE AirFone. I'd rather use my cell.
cghh

join:2001-01-15
Milpitas, CA

Re: great, cell phones replacing the crying baby

Verizon Wireless customers can have their cellphone forwarded to Airfone. It is treated like a "roaming" call: $0.69/minute. Or you can pay a $10/mo fee and then calls are $0.10/min. Automatically "unforwards" when you get off the plane.

tiger72
SexaT duorP
Premium
join:2001-03-28
Saint Louis, MO
clubs:
·T-Mobile US
·RoadRunner Cable

said by 91439306 See Profile:

Just consider what it's like to get an $82 bill for a 5-minute phone call from GTE AirFone. I'd rather use my cell.
just consider what it's like sitting next to the prick who wants to do his full business meeting on the plane.
(yelling)
"YEAH BOB, I KNOW WHAT YOU'RE SAYING BUT I JUST CAN'T GIVE IN, THERE'S NO WAY I CAN DO THAT - HOLD ON I CAN BARELY HEAR YOU. OH YOU WANT ME TO SPEAK UP? NO PROBLEM. THANK GOD I HAVE MY CELL PHONE SO I CAN STROKE MY EGO EVEN MORE!"

Forget about business now, how about teenage love-birds talking THE WHOLE flight? "Ohh chrissy i've got the HUUUUGEST crush on timmy in 2nd period, hehehehehe! yeah i'm like, SOOOOO into him. I like, can't wait for him to like, ask me out so we can like... like... like each other! HEHEHE!"

That sets chills down my spine already.

I can truly see people asking "please sit me next to a quiet couple with 2 babies - it's so much more pleasant."

outlaw phones



Re: great, cell phones replacing the crying baby

I can just see it now...

Tthe airlines create specific flights that are "cell-phone" enabled / disabled.. kinda like what they did with smoking / non-smoking flights.

Worse yet, when you book a flight one of the new quesitons will be; "Do you want to be on a Cell-phone use area of the plane or not?" I can just imagine folks that want to use thier cell phones in flight will book a seat in the non-cell phone area, then get up and walk to the area of the plane; stand in the isle and make their calls...

This is gonna get ugly

MikeRaach

join:2000-12-05
Martinez, CA

said by Aleck79 See Profile:

I can just see it now, no more jokes about the crying baby on the airline, its going to be the asshole on the cell phone :x
Is someone talking on their phone any different than that person talking to the person next to them? Babies are just annoying, but I don't see this as being a big problem.
--
Come get free stuff at freestuffnation.com
dave
Premium,MVM
join:2000-05-04
not in ohio

phone is not required

I have resolved that if the person next to me has the right to talk into a phone, loudly and past the point of annoyance, then I have the right to talk into a non-phone, loudly and past the point of annoyance.

mustang03282

join:2003-01-10
Bridgeton, NJ
clubs:

Re: phone is not required

easy solution eat some air line food and 10 min later you should be able to fart louder then the person on the phone. It may not shut them up but it will make them move and then they are someone els's problem

fireflier
Coffee. . .Need Coffee
Premium
join:2001-05-25
Limbo
·Skype

Re: great, cell phones replacing the crying baby

Unfortunately, some people seem to assume that if the cellular connection isn't great or there's background noise that SPEAKING LOUDER FIXES THE PROBLEM.

In public places, you can frequently distinguish who's carrying on a cell conversation from others carrying on interpersonal conversation without even seeing them. Many of them basically scream into the phone.

That would get really annoying sitting next to someone on a plane who's trying to look important or is just bored and wanting to yak with their friend/girlfriend/boyfriend/kid/parent/co-worker, etc.

If people actually carried on cellular conversations at reasonable volume, it probably wouldn't be a problem.
--
When people are free to do as they please, they usually imitate each other.

tnroroc
Let's Rock

join:2001-04-25
Matawan, NJ

The someone talking to someone next to themselves has only that person to talk to. With a cellphone, this same annoying person can to to an unlimited amount of people.
--
rok - Enjoy this game called life, nobody is actually keeping score.

slimpickinz

join:2003-11-29
Conyers, GA

At the supermarket, when the person in front of you is talking about NOTHING and is not paying attention to the cashier...then they want to write a check or need a price check on an item ...I tell them to get off the damn phone & pay attention...
9 times out of 10 they hang up and move on. I have NO PROBLEM letting someone know I do not appreciate their phone conversation when it is infringing on me and my space. Just how important can a call be? You do have voice mail and an earphone, right?

AtomicZero

join:2004-11-24
West Palm Beach, FL

said by Aleck79 See Profile:

I can just see it now, no more jokes about the crying baby on the airline, its going to be the asshole on the cell phone :x
Yep that'll be me next to ya. Bluetooth handsfree in ear blabbing away to someone I have to business blabbing with at the moment, bouncing my tirelessly wailing baby on knee while clicking away on my Wi-Fi with the other hand and smoking a cigarette [cuz I'm hoping they will lift that ban too]

phunkysmell

@comcast.net

1. if you want to talk (and annoy people) you will have to connect through the mini transceiver/picocell on the plane so it will be as expensive as the AirPhones in the seatbacks (so the annoying people shouldn't be any worse than they are already with AirPhones)

2. if they lift the ban we'll be able to use our SmartPhones and PDA phones to play games, listen to music, read e-books, etc. without the flight attendants forcing you to shut it off and put it away
Andromeda451

join:2004-04-08
Queen Creek, AZ
So, is there a penalty for sticking the cell phone into the abusers ear? Must be at least 5 minutes in the penalty box...

DrewCapu
Giant Diehard

join:2001-12-19
California
clubs:

As long as it's only

on flights that have a movie showing. Then it'll be like going to the theater.

tiger72
SexaT duorP
Premium
join:2001-03-28
Saint Louis, MO
clubs:
·T-Mobile US
·RoadRunner Cable

Re: As long as it's only

said by DrewCapu See Profile:

on flights that have a movie showing. Then it'll be like going to the theater.
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

metsfan489
METS - 2006 NL EAST

join:2004-10-11
Oakland Gardens, NY
clubs:

Cell Phones when we could relax?!?!?

We don't need to hear those stupid loud cell phone users on an airplane too. This is going to be almost as bad as those babies screaming in the back of coach. All I care about is free wi-fi on all planes

ssj4android
Redefining Reality

join:2002-04-14
Wyoming, MI

Re: Cell Phones when we could relax?!?!?

With free wifi, couldn't people just use voip and talk even more for cheap/free?
JTHOMAS28

join:2002-02-21
Newtonville, MA

pointless

finally. now we're not forced to use those expensive sky phones. but pretty pointless becuase i never get reception past a certain altitude, unless they offer service inside the planes from service providers above a certain altitude.

koolman2
Premium
join:2002-10-01
Anchorage, AK
·GCI.net

Re: pointless

quote:
"...at its lowest power setting under control of a "pico cell" (a mini-coverage area) located on the aircraft."
They'll have a mini-transceiver on the plane itself.
--
A bus station is where a bus stops. A train station is where a train stops. On my desk, I have a work station.

AbBaZaBbA
Premium
join:2002-07-10
Wildomar, CA
·Verizon FIOS

Re: pointless

said by koolman2 See Profile:

quote:
"...at its lowest power setting under control of a "pico cell" (a mini-coverage area) located on the aircraft."
They'll have a mini-transceiver on the plane itself.
Yea and can you imagine how much they're gonna charge to use your phone on the plane.... I'm sure it'll be insanely expensive.

Googled
Yay, I have FIOS

join:2001-08-13
Orchard Park, NY
·VoicePulse

Re: pointless

said by AbBaZaBbA See ProfileYea and can you imagine how much they're gonna charge to use your phone on the plane.... I'm sure it'll be insanely expensive. [/BQUOTE:

It depends. I'm quite certain that airlines they will be more than happy to set up co-branded service with a cellular carrier. The people who have that cellular service will then be rewarded by flying with the airline by being able to use the pico cell for free. The airline will be rewarded by customers of that cell phone company purchasing tickets.
averagedude

join:2002-01-30
Mesa, AZ
Important Question:

At what point will the turn on/off the picocell.

If I were the airlines I would leave the picocell on full time - that way when people call their significant other to pick them up, the air lines will make a killing.

Trel
Good Evening
Premium
join:2002-10-08
Hillsborough, NJ
picky, they lift you closer to the sattelite and you STILL don't get a signal
ndurkin

join:2001-05-04
Burbank, IL

Re: pointless

Cell phones don't use satellites....

tiger72
SexaT duorP
Premium
join:2001-03-28
Saint Louis, MO
clubs:
·T-Mobile US
·RoadRunner Cable

Re: pointless

said by ndurkin See Profile:

Cell phones don't use satellites....
i'm pretty sure he's kidding.
Thaler
Premium
join:2004-02-02
Encino, CA


1 edit

Just Get Me to my Damn Destination on Time, Thanks

Bah, with all the current inconveniences with flying, they clearly don't have their s*** all together in their own business, let alone providing "luxuries". Overcharge me to be crammed into a damn tiny seat for 8 hours, living off 4 oz. drinks and pretzels WHILE running several hours late...cell phone use is the least of my concerns.

Hey aviation industry, could you JUST get me from point A to point B reliably on time? Some breathing room and a "meal" not consisting of condiment packages would be a nice extra...but I won't worry ya'll much about that.
keyboard5684

join:2001-08-01
Youngsville, PA
·Teliax VOIP
·WestPAnet Inc.
·WestPAnet Inc. CA..

Re: Just Get Me to my Damn Destination on Time, Th

I agree but do not think this is really an AirLine decision, it is an FCC choice. If the ban is lifted then the debate would certainly come up within the airlines.

I personally like people to shut up on the plane. Not really in the mood to "chit chat" after rushing to the airport, to slow down, then wait let alone have to sit and listen to some teenage girl babble on and on to her girlfriend about how Joey left her best friends number on his phone.

I think they should take out those stupid phones in the seats, keep cell phone usage off, and maybe add more TVs with headphones or something. I like the meal idea too!

I also, since I am going on and on, really get annoyed at how once you land the cell phones just all come on. Everybody turns em on and starts chatting away. (They could just wait until the terminal). There is more annoying chit-chat at that moment about "how horrible the flight was" or if Spot has gotten over his explosive diarrhea. This is a prime example of how much worse your flight could get.

WI-FI would be nice. Just let me surf the web, quietly. You cannot really here my keyboard over the aircraft noise anyways.

joako
Premium
join:2000-09-07
/dev/null
·AT&T U-Verse

Re: Just Get Me to my Damn Destination on Time, Th

said by keyboard5684 See Profile:

I agree but do not think this is really an AirLine decision, it is an FCC choice. If the ban is lifted then the debate would certainly come up within the airlines.

I personally like people to shut up on the plane. Not really in the mood to "chit chat" after rushing to the airport, to slow down, then wait let alone have to sit and listen to some teenage girl babble on and on to her girlfriend about how Joey left her best friends number on his phone.

I think they should take out those stupid phones in the seats, keep cell phone usage off, and maybe add more TVs with headphones or something. I like the meal idea too!

I also, since I am going on and on, really get annoyed at how once you land the cell phones just all come on. Everybody turns em on and starts chatting away. (They could just wait until the terminal). There is more annoying chit-chat at that moment about "how horrible the flight was" or if Spot has gotten over his explosive diarrhea. This is a prime example of how much worse your flight could get.

WI-FI would be nice. Just let me surf the web, quietly. You cannot really here my keyboard over the aircraft noise anyways.
So you don't use the phone at all after the plane lands? "Hey the plane just landed, could you please pick me up" really speeds up things...
--
I'm joakimsen and I approve this message.»sveasoft.pifiu.com
keyboard5684

join:2001-08-01
Youngsville, PA
·Teliax VOIP
·WestPAnet Inc.
·WestPAnet Inc. CA..

Re: Just Get Me to my Damn Destination on Time, Th

Well, no. Usually I can get off the aircraft, which takes maybe 10 minutes, then do it. In most cases though I end up driving myself after I get off the plane.

My point was more to express how it could be, with half those people using there phones in flight it could be a nightmare.

footballdude
Premium
join:2002-08-13
Imperial, MO

Re: Just Get Me to my Damn Destination on Time, Thanks

said by Thaler See Profile:

Hey aviation industry, could you JUST get me from point A to point B reliably on time?
Try flying Southwest. They consistenly outperform the other airlines I've flown in comfort and being on time. You just have to show up at the gate early to get a good seat number. They also have the benefit of being dirt cheap.

I can't tell you how many times I've flown the TWA cattle car from St Louis to San Francisco. Four hours with my knees in my chest and someone's elbows in my ribs. With Southwest I have to stop off in Phoenix so it takes longer but the seats are much nicer and the crew is much friendlier.
Thaler
Premium
join:2004-02-02
Encino, CA

Re: Just Get Me to my Damn Destination on Time, Thanks

I might just do that...usually when I fly, they treat everyone like the next potential Osama.

I'm sorry, but just because I fly coach and ask for my condiment-sized bag of pretzels...DOES NOT mean I have intentions of taking over the flight! I just MIGHT be hungry, ya know?

footballdude
Premium
join:2002-08-13
Imperial, MO

Re: Just Get Me to my Damn Destination on Time, Thanks

said by Thaler See Profile:

I just MIGHT be hungry, ya know?
Definitely do not fly TWA(American) if you're hungry. Every flight I've been on longer than two hours they serve sandwiches and chips, which admittedly doesn't sound all that bad. They freeze the sandwiches, however, and let them thaw right before serving so the buns are always soggy. Yuck. They also serve chips that look like factory leftovers. Honestly, the last flight I was on they served vinegar flavored chips. I didn't even know there was such a thing as vinegar flavored chips. I taken to refusing the food altogether. I usually stop at Walgreens on the way to the airport and buy one of those individual sized cans of Pringles and just put it in my pocket for the flight. Since it's made of paper fiber, it doesn't set off the metal detector.
Thaler
Premium
join:2004-02-02
Encino, CA

Re: Just Get Me to my Damn Destination on Time, Thanks

said by footballdude See Profile:

said by Thaler See Profile:


I just MIGHT be hungry, ya know?
Definitely do not fly TWA(American) if you're hungry. Every flight I've been on longer than two hours they serve sandwiches and chips, which admittedly doesn't sound all that bad. They freeze the sandwiches, however, and let them thaw right before serving so the buns are always soggy. Yuck. They also serve chips that look like factory leftovers. Honestly, the last flight I was on they served vinegar flavored chips. I didn't even know there was such a thing as vinegar flavored chips. I taken to refusing the food altogether. I usually stop at Walgreens on the way to the airport and buy one of those individual sized cans of Pringles and just put it in my pocket for the flight. Since it's made of paper fiber, it doesn't set off the metal detector.
Well, it doesn't have so much to do with me being hungry persay...but how asking for the most minor of services isolates me out as a "security risk".

For example, I was sitting in the first coach row on an airline, and had a biological need cry out mid-flight. So, I move towards the front lavatory, only to be shoved back by a stewardess saying I couldn't approach the cockpit. Upon telling her I needed to use the restroom, she pointed me towards the WAAAAY back of the plane - a path which would require vaulting a stewardess, a small family, and a drink cart. I kindly pointed to the bathroom a few feet away, but she gave a firm "HELL NO" response. Upon asking why, she said "It's a security risk. You might be rushing the cockpit."

Yeah, um...whatever. No offense hun, but nobody with that full a bladder is going to rush ANYTHING, let alone a locked cockpit door.
niko01

join:2004-01-19
Houston, TX

oh dear Lord

I can't believe that anyone would want the ban lifted. Stuck on a plane for 4 hours with some loud-mouth jackass blabbing not a foot away - having to talk over the loud-mouth 17 year old girl sitting behind you - "like, oh my GAWD..." - who of course is purposely talking loud in order to catch the attention of the 20-something rebel without a clue talking to his buds on the ground about all the super-important stuff they will do when he lands... and on and on. I've seen this in my nightmares.... the horror....

Bottom line - if you really think that the outside world can't survive 3-4 straight hours without hearing from you, you need to get over yourself.

Signed,

Grumpy Old Man Higgins
celticguy

join:2004-10-08
Atlanta, GA

Re: oh dear Lord

Amen.

I would never thought that could be any situation worse than putting up with a screaming baby during flight (mostly because those poor souls are enduring painful earaches). But having to put up with those lingering pompous, loud phone conversations, particularly in first class, is far worse. It's bad enough to have to endure them while on the ground. Delta Crown rooms have a quiet zones where cell phone usage is forbidden.

The airlines should have a small restricted area for cell phone users in the back of the plane, just like they did for smokers in the seventies.
TheGhost
Premium
join:2003-01-03
Lake Forest, IL
clubs:
·AT&T U-Verse
·Comcast

Re: oh dear Lord

Actually, cell phone use would most likely be relegated to the front of the planes, not the rear. Frequent travelers would be the most likely users of cell phones and they normally get preferential treatment (first seating, seating near the front, etc), so I guess the rear of the plan could be the "quiet" zone.

Slidetbone
Mazin Go
Premium
join:2002-11-10
Land O Lakes, FL

Re: oh dear Lord

said by TheGhost See Profile:

Actually, cell phone use would most likely be relegated to the front of the planes, not the rear. Frequent travelers would be the most likely users of cell phones and they normally get preferential treatment (first seating, seating near the front, etc), so I guess the rear of the plan could be the "quiet" zone.
..and will be the ones that will pay the big roamer fee. The article says the plane will use a type of transceiver. That means a handoff to a roaming carrier which means roaming charges for those that do not carry those plans.
It also states that the handsets will have to be capable of transmitting less than the 0.6 watt it normally transmits.
Lastly and for those that have used Airfone; line of site works differently and unpredictably for a cellphone at higher altitudes. Yuo expect the phone to work the same way it does on the ground. It won't! The technology will be no different, just that you added a pico cell (middle man) between you and the receiving party. This will not be a free ride.

HardwareGeek

join:2003-11-15
Brooklyn, NY

Don't lift the ban

I really hope they do not lift this ban. It pisses me off enough people yap away loudly on trains. I can imagine the yapping on flights.
--
Email/MSN: Michael at hardwaregeeks.comAIM: MikeR35292
flatierii

join:2004-04-18
Fort Lauderdale, FL

im tired of the cellphone whiners

Please people I can see people not being allowed in to use a phone in a movie of performance. But on bus, train or plane that is no reason to ban cellphones. Then problem is that cellphones dont work properly so people need to yell in it. What is the difference between people have a conversation with another person at a resturant or on a bus. I know I know you dont like the one way conversation well the conversation doesn't include you dont listen. If someone talks in a normal tone there is nothing wrong with a cell conversation.

Logan 5
Silver and Black and blue in 2009
Premium,MVM
join:2001-05-25
The WasteLAN
·Pacific Bell - SBC

Re: im tired of the cellphone whiners

Lets see if we understand each other correctly:

said by flatierii See Profile:
Then problem is that cellphones dont work properly so people need to yell in it.
Well, WHO's fault is that?? The Cellphone makers or the idiot screaming in my ear sitting next/across to/from me on a flight who has no manners. If he can't use his defective equipment, all the better for the rest of us who enjoy the peace & quiet a cell ban brings to a flight...

said by flatierii See Profile:
I know I know you dont like the one way conversation well the conversation doesn't include you dont listen.
See #1 Above. People really have no choice but to listen when Mr. Drunk businessman in coach is screaming at his wife/girlfriend/lover at 35,000 feet...1 way, 2 way conversations mean nothing when they're being conducted at 50 or 60dB and fueled by several mixed drinks.....

Let's just leave the existing rules alone shall we? Why fix what isin't broke?

Combat Chuck
Too Many Cannibals
Premium
join:2001-11-29
Erie, PA


1 edit

Re: im tired of the cellphone whiners

said by Logan 5 See Profile:

See #1 Above. People really have no choice but to listen when Mr. Drunk businessman in coach is screaming at his wife/girlfriend/lover at 35,000 feet...1 way, 2 way conversations mean nothing when they're being conducted at 50 or 60dB and fueled by several mixed drinks.....
I've found that a good way to get people to be more sensitive to the where and how of their having a cell phone conversations is to begin talking loudly about whatever the person on the cell is talking about.

They'll be PO'd about you paying attention but they'll also either cut short the call or at least lower their voice.

I have no problem with removing the cell phone regs on aircraft (they're mostly a sham anyway), but in return people on cell phones need to learn how to not be total jackasses when using said phone. Problem is we can't even get people who need 2 seats (nor the airlines who continue to permit this practice with a shrug) to respect the fact that sitting halfway on their neighbors lap is inappropriate, which in my mind ranks a much higher inconvenience.
--
sprry; I kust gpt s new leubprd////////keyboard

Combat Chuck
Too Many Cannibals
Premium
join:2001-11-29
Erie, PA

said by flatierii See Profile:

Then problem is that cellphones dont work properly so people need to yell in it.
Wrong, The problem is that people think that yelling into the cell phone fixes whatever problem they are having with their cell phone...including not being able to hear the person on the other end.
--
sprry; I kust gpt s new leubprd////////keyboard

ylen131

join:2000-02-09
Canoga Park, CA

to little to late

Any airline that offer internet can also support voice over internet protocol. So basically regardless if they lift this ban or not people will still be able to talk on the phone.

See 7 replies to this post
ebubman

join:2002-01-17
Enola, PA

say it ain't so...

i'll go out on a limb & predict that in-air episodes of violence will rise when ignorant people have new ways to annoy people. i for one will check out the offerings from koss for those no-noise, don't bug me headphones. bub
JaxChris

join:2004-04-03
Middleburg, FL

"The Captain has turned on the no cell phone sign"

At this point there is no connectivity for US air passengers. One or two Europeans have it. I do however have mobile ip service on my cell thru Nextel that I use on my laptop in the car when I'm out doing work as a Real Estate Appraiser. If they set up "pico cells" on planes to forward GSM and CDMA signals to/from the ground then that means that some of us will have internet in flight.

If I have to go by means of my phone to get internet in flight, then so be it... I'll be too audible pre-occupied with my headphones on listening to music and surfing the web the whole time to ever be distracted by some loud mouth, drunk, or self-absorbed person talking on his cell phone. And granted my own statement sounds just as absorbed... but it's my 2 cents that are equal to any of yours.

I bet most people here that either like or dislike the cell ban are just itching for kind of in-flight wireless connection. I see no difference, everyone has their preferred method of distraction while on a plane... let them have choices.

Maybe if it gets really bad, after the ban is lifted, the airlines will be nice and have "quiet times" during flights longer than 3 hours so that all the whiners can rest in peace. Sheesh, like people won't adapt to the environment they are in. MP3 players are still climbing in sales, I'm sure anyone who isn't talking on a phone will be listening to something else after a while. Travellers like choices and experienced travellers always have their in-flight toys.

Getting too long here.... enough said. Line Test should be done, I'm out.

GilbertMark
Premium
join:2001-05-02
Gilbert, AZ
·Cox HSI

yes

the guy on the cellphone IS more annoying than the two people sitting in front of you having a conversation

i find when people are on cell phones (or even using microphones) there is this phenomenon where they need to talk extra loud for some reason (or what if they had a bad connection and had to) and suddenly their conversation is the most important thing in the world to everyone within earshot, oh goodie

i guess you could just kick the back of their chair

people chit chatting about the banal details of their life just to say "hey i'm calling you from a plane" shouldn't be allowed to disturb everyone within earshot

maybe they can make a cell phone only flight or section on the plane
keyboard5684

join:2001-08-01
Youngsville, PA
·Teliax VOIP
·WestPAnet Inc.
·WestPAnet Inc. CA..

Re: yes

The problem with planes is that, unless you are in first class, you are pretty freakin close to 17 people or more. You are so crammed into that airplane that an earshot means you just killed 17+ people.

Planes are uncomfortable as it is. Flying just sucks, even first class, and is not the most pleasant experience there is. The circumstances leading up to the flight just makes you want to pray that you have no noise and can put your chair back without spilling the persons drink behind you.

You get raped in security, tortured by delays, and dragged through the mud in many other ways. Once you get on the flight you should have as little misery as possible.

MIKETSG

join:2003-01-20
Naugatuck, CT

Re: yes

This is a dangerous proposal... Coming from a pilot! Whats the matter with people!?

X_Digit
Binary Enhanced
Premium
join:2003-06-12
Mansfield, TX

Come on guys...

I see alot of moanin' and groanin' in here... but I don't see the issue with it. If you guys are REALLY concerned about the "annoying cell-phone user", then perhaps you should bring a good set of ear-plugs with you. I swear, there'll ALWAYS be somethin' to bitch about.

Feel free to pick yours:

A) Loud-mouth, crying baby
B) Loud-mouth cell-phone user
C) Tight over-crowded seating
D) Turbulence
E) 90 year-old with 5 gallons of perfume
F) Snoring idiot beside/behind you
G) Sound of person banging his laptop keyboard
H) The size of your meal/snack
I) The temperature
J) And on, and on, and on...
xirian
Premium
join:2003-01-26
Beacon, NY

screw cell phones

screw having a cell phone on the flight. Just give me some damn wifi even if its slow so I can quietly chat with my friends (not for $6/minute either, I want a fixed price that isnt $90 per flight) without disturbing others. I dont want to talk on my phone when im trying to relax on a flight, and dont want to hear others.
N Yazdi

join:2004-04-19
Omaha, NE

ive tried............

using my cell phone on the plane before but ive never gotten any signal, i have before on smaller private craft that flew at much lower altitudes and have recieved signal but never before on a commercial plane. Has anyone ever recieved signal on a commercial jet flying at alritude?
N Yazdi

join:2004-04-19
Omaha, NE

Re: ive tried............

altitude

SOLdesign
Did I drink a shot of Irrational Whore?
Premium
join:2002-07-29
Woodland Hills, CA

solution

this is what I do when I am around someone talking loudly on a cell phone. I repeat everything they say at the same volume. They get the point pretty quickly.
--
-I need a beer. Soon.
ralf1

join:2001-02-09
Sugar Land, TX

One Solution

When I am near someone using a cell phone in an irritating fashion, I make a huge show of taking detailed notes of thier conversation. Its amazing how quickly they either shut up or go away.
slyphoxj

join:2002-06-23
Brook Park, OH
·AT&T Midwest

A Better Solution

Two words:

Text Messaging

You can carry on a conversation in complete silence and you won't annoy anybody. And it might be cheaper too (depending on your plan).

Of course, don't forget to set your phone to "silent" or "vibrate only" mode .

balazone
60 billion
Premium
join:2002-04-01
Wheeling, WV
·Comcast Formerly ..

Ring tones - I hate them

The only thing more annoying then being forced to listen to people yap on their cell phones are the people who insist on listening to the entire stupid 5 minute ring tone they downloaded. And then when they finally answer the call, the person calling has hung up because they are tired of waiting. If they do allow phones on planes all the phones should auto-set to vibrate.

Chinabound
Premium
join:2002-12-21
Antioch, IL
clubs:
·Comcast

No mobile phones, please

Thankfully, I am rarely on a domestic flight here in the states. I don't know how many of you actually travel abroad, but to those that do, I am sure you have noticed that it is us, the Americans, who cannot behave themselves very well. We expect everything to be perfect - our seats, the food, other passengers........
Because of the tremendous lack of patience and tolerance we americans have towards each other, and just about everything if it isn't perfect, there will be many problems. I always bring earplugs and an eye mask when I fly if I need to try to sleep or relax. I can see now these two items may be even more important to me if they allow mobile phone use.
I am really surprised that people can't manage their lives well enough to just relax for a few hours and stay off the phone. Talk to your neighbor.....play with the crying baby.....enjoy the view out the window. Try to show some interest in something other than yourself. You may find life as intriguing as I do.

garagerock
Premium
join:2002-06-14
Louisville, KY

Re: No mobile phones, please

said by Chinabound See Profile:

Thankfully, I am rarely on a domestic flight here in the states. I don't know how many of you actually travel abroad, but to those that do, I am sure you have noticed that it is us, the Americans, who cannot behave themselves very well. We expect everything to be perfect - our seats, the food, other passengers........
Because of the tremendous lack of patience and tolerance we americans have towards each other, and just about everything if it isn't perfect, there will be many problems. I always bring earplugs and an eye mask when I fly if I need to try to sleep or relax. I can see now these two items may be even more important to me if they allow mobile phone use.
I am really surprised that people can't manage their lives well enough to just relax for a few hours and stay off the phone. Talk to your neighbor.....play with the crying baby.....enjoy the view out the window. Try to show some interest in something other than yourself. You may find life as intriguing as I do.
I agree in theory with your statements. What most are missing here is simply the lack of cell phone etiquette in general-not just on planes, but everywhere else.

The confined space of an airplane seems to add to the agitation factor exponentially, like elevators, cars, trains, subways, etc. Americans like their personal space-if you've travelled abroad you know what I mean-and cell phones have invaded that personal space. Our culture's attitude is "do what I say, not what I do" so therefore we can yap all day about astroturf but can't stand it when our neighbor is cooing to their girlfriend on the exact same phone.

Just because we can call instantly wherever, whenever we want doesn't necessarily mean we should. And if you just have to save that extra 4 minutes waiting for your ride by calling as soon as the plane lands, why not exercise some respect and speak in a polite tone, at a polite volume? Consideration for others is an adult skill we've shitcanned in the name of "progress". Ballyhoo to progress.

BTW: I have 2 cellphones, and use them frequently. Nobody is getting rich on the plans I have, but they are useful, when used appropriately. I don't use them unless I have to, and only in the privacy of my stopped vehicle, office, or home, so unless my fuzzy dice have ears, I'm not irritating anyone. Just to show I practice what I preach...
Forums » In Flight Cell Phone Ban May Be Lifted


Sunday, 08-Nov 18:10:37 Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Hosting by www.nac.net - DSL,Hosting & Co-lo | feedback | contact
over 10 years online! © 1999-2009 dslreports.com.republican-creole