Search:  

 
 
   News
newer
story category Fiber To The Home In Kutztown, PA
Low cable prices but slow fiber speeds...
09:31AM Wednesday Jul 09 2008 by Karl Bode
tags: Fiber · competition · business · municipal
The Carroll County Times profiles one of the oldest municipal fiber deployments in the nation in Kutztown, Pennsylvania. In Kutztown, residents pay $18 per month for basic cable and $35 per month for expanded cable, a move that has forced local competitor Service Electric Cablevision to lower rates. Looking at the pricing page of Hometown Utilicom, one isn't exactly impressed by the speeds being offered over a FTTH system: while $25.00 gets you 2Mbps/128kbps, $80 a month only nets you a symmetrical 3Mbps connection.

Related:
  1. Clarksville Fiber Rolls On
  2. iProvo FTTH Losing Customers
  3. Utopia Not So Picture Perfect
  4. iProvo Sold To Broadweave For $40 Million
  5. Locals Try To Keep Utopia Afloat
  6. Thursday Evening Links
  7. Wednesday Evening Links
  8. Friday Evening Links
Forums » Fiber To The Home In Kutztown, PA
view: topics flat text 
Post a:

wifi4milez
In Need Of Garbage Pail Kids 1st Series

join:2004-08-07
New York, NY

They do offer faster speeds

The link above leads you to a page that says they do offer a 10Mbps download option, however there is no price listed.
jesseb_66

join:2002-12-06
Tucson, AZ

Re: They do offer faster speeds

128kbps up on FTTH? that is freaking horrible... even for $25.
EPS

join:2008-02-13
Hingham, MA

Re: They do offer faster speeds

Hm- is this a technological limitation (used old technology in deployment and now can't afford to upgrade to a modern system) or just the provider refusing to provide higher speeds?

wifi4milez
In Need Of Garbage Pail Kids 1st Series

join:2004-08-07
New York, NY
·Sprint Mobile Broa..
·RoadRunner Cable
·BroadVoice

Re: They do offer faster speeds

said by EPS See Profile :

Hm- is this a technological limitation (used old technology in deployment and now can't afford to upgrade to a modern system) or just the provider refusing to provide higher speeds?
Its probably a combination of the fact that there is very little demand for higher speeds, coupled with the fact that to provide them "just because" would be very expensive. The town itself only has 5000 residents, so realistically there are probably not more than a handful (if that) of people who are even interested in higher speeds or paying more for their internet. Then take into account the wholesale cost of the bandwidth required (that the provider would need to purchase) in order to have a higher tier available, and what they are doing makes good business sense.
--
If history teaches us anything, it teaches that simple-minded appeasement or wishful thinking about our adversaries is folly.
-Ronald Reagan-
DoRight

join:2007-07-20
Mechanicsburg, PA
·Comcast
·Sprint Mobile Broa..
·Verizon FIOS

Amish love it..

Kutztown is a rural area with little need for anything more then what they are offering. There are two things in that area Kutztown University and Pennsylvania Dutch.. And there is nothing wrong with that. I wish more areas would have local competition like this.
thevorpal

join:2007-11-16
Endicott, NY

This IS amazing. It is Kutztown afterall.

The fact that Kutztown has fiber at all is pretty damned amazing. The area, even today, is very rural.

While it isn't the heart of Amish country, you have to admit that any place getting fiber that is also known as an area with a large Amish population is pretty amazing.

It does show that something like this can exist. The prices may be higher, but they aren't so high as to be out of reach from the average resident.
jester121

join:2003-08-09
Lake Zurich, IL
·ViaTalk

Re: This IS amazing. It is Kutztown afterall.

The fact that you're getting all excited about it just because it's fiber says a lot too. The speed is crap, the price is mediocre, so what does it matter whether it's being delivered over fiber or barbed wire fence?

This might as well be a story about how evil broadband providers cheat customers by only offering 128k up, and leave off the bit about the layer 1 media completely.
jgantert

join:2004-06-02
Columbia, MD

Re: This IS amazing. It is Kutztown afterall.

Well, fiber is going to be a lot more reliable than copper for starters. Plus, I'm sure that can upgrade in the future if there is a need. Still, pretty amazing that such a rural area is wired as it is! Way to go!

espaeth
Misanthrope
Premium
join:2001-04-21
Minneapolis, MN
·voip.ms
·Callcentric
·VoiceStick
·ViaTalk
·Comcast
·Embarq

Re: This IS amazing. It is Kutztown afterall.

said by jgantert See Profile :

Well, fiber is going to be a lot more reliable than an early 20th century installed base of copper for starters.
Ajusted it for you.

The thing fiber really has going for it is the lack of susceptibility to EMI/RFI, otherwise copper and fiber are on-par for reliability with a slight edge actually going to copper. (no optics to burn out, copper wire is less fragile than glass, no reliance on power utility for functionality at the residence, etc) They're both affected by backhoe fade / trucks hitting poles, attached equipment failure, etc.

NetAdmin

join:2008-05-22

Re: This IS amazing. It is Kutztown afterall.

said by espaeth See Profile :

The thing fiber really has going for it is the lack of susceptibility to EMI/RFI, otherwise copper and fiber are on-par for reliability with a slight edge actually going to copper. (no optics to burn out, copper wire is less fragile than glass, no reliance on power utility for functionality at the residence, etc) They're both affected by backhoe fade / trucks hitting poles, attached equipment failure, etc.
You forgot that copper installations act as conductors in the event of lightning and the occasional high voltage electric arcs/wires down/crossed wires/etc. Copper also suffers from environmental issues more - water intrusion and related shorts and unintentional grounds, temperature related contraction and expansion, etc.

That slight edge you talk about has also been erased by some of the new products coming out.
--
---
Over ten plus years of carrying The Clue Bat...

MadMANN
Premium
join:2005-08-19
·Comcast

said by jgantert See Profile :

Well, fiber is going to be a lot more reliable than copper for starters.
Not really. If you dig, you will find that that system has had about the same amount of downtime as SECV. And SECV may be a mom & pop cable company, but they offer top of the line services such as appx 50 HDs, 10/1 service, and phone. The fiber company has nothing close to what they offer.
DoRight

join:2007-07-20
Mechanicsburg, PA
·Comcast
·Sprint Mobile Broa..
·Verizon FIOS

Just because your in the Chicago Area and get more doesn't mean you can belittle this area. There are more cows then people in the Kutztown Area. For a company to even invest in fiber in this area is awesome. And yes I know Lake Zurich is 45 mins to an hour outside Chicago.
jester121

join:2003-08-09
Lake Zurich, IL
·ViaTalk

Re: This IS amazing. It is Kutztown afterall.

As a former resident of Murrysville, DuBois, State College, and the Philly burbs, I'm pretty familiar with the demographics and geography of Pennsylvania, and the fact that I'm on the internet and can type means I can belittle anything I want to. Even in Mechanicsburg (isn't that where the famous wing place is?) you speak English, so you'll note that nowhere in my post did I bash Kutztown or belittle anyone.

I'm not suggesting that the fiber network isn't nice; simply that if their main offering is 2M/128k service, it's not all that exciting.

If they have a long term plan to leverage the infrastructure into something worthwhile then it would be exciting. At least for Kutztownians.
DoRight

join:2007-07-20
Mechanicsburg, PA

Re: This IS amazing. It is Kutztown afterall.

Not sure about any famous wings around here... We have the awesome 80's hairband Poison.. So there..

heat84

join:2004-03-11
Fort Lauderdale, FL
·AT&T Southeast

Re: This IS amazing. It is Kutztown afterall.

said by DoRight See Profile :

Not sure about any famous wings around here... We have the awesome 80's hairband Poison.. So there..
Considering what the lead singer has been doing latley (a shitty reality show on VH1), I wouldn't be to proud of that.
DoRight

join:2007-07-20
Mechanicsburg, PA

Re: This IS amazing. It is Kutztown afterall.

Did you even live in the 80's?
Rexx

join:2002-12-02
Kutztown, PA
wow, kutztownian, I've never been called that.

As for the speeds and price, I have Verizon dsl now but with the removal of most newsgroups I dont think that will last long...
majortom1029

join:2006-10-19
Lindenhurst, NY

hmm

I am guessing the problem is money. They probably dont have the money for a big enough conenction to the internet to support giving their subscribers faster speeds.

Boricua65
Oye, chico

join:2002-01-26
Puerto Rico

Oh so good

...a move that has forced local competitor Service Electric Cablevision to lower rates. Who said competition wasn't good. As for the speeds, I find it adequate for what is probably be used for. Although the upload would be painfully slow, for a town of that size, I don't see the infrastructure being used by everyone all at once..
--
Yo te digo, el mundo esta jodido

ib50MbSoon
Formerly TwoKDialup
Premium
join:2002-06-07
Coloma, MI

.

I would expect muni-fiber to be slightly more expensive because the municipality has to serve everyone in their geographic boundaries.

OTOH, with the exception of a few token deployments, telecoms often practice redlining and service only lucrative areas.
--
Comcast has spoiled me rotten!
Selenia

join:2006-09-22
Pittsfield, MA
·RoadRunner Cable

Has the point been missed?

I think this article conveys the viability of fiber as infrastructure for even a town like Kutztown. This kind of infrastructure is not only about speed, but also cost and flexibility. If you're wiring from scratch, fiber infrastructure gives more than the alternatives dollar for dollar. These rates are really low for a local company wiring for 1 community. We have a local company delivering dsl over Verizon's lines(but with their own CO). $60 a month and a $175 install charge nets you 1.5 mbit down, 384 kbit up. oh, and you have to buy your own modem. They don't do loaners.

odog
Cable Centric Vendor Biased
Premium
join:2001-08-05
Norcross, GA
clubs:
·Metrocast Communic..
·Comcast
·Vonage


edit:
July 9th, @11:10AM

love the FUD

»www.hometownutilicom.org/Service···net.html

quote:
Our Internet is second to none! Light vs. Copper! Did you know that light travels at a speed of 570 million miles per hour? Still think copper DSL and cable modems are fast enough?
Do they know thats a useless fact and that information actually travels slower through fiber than through copper(coax or twisted pair).

»en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Velocity_o···pagation
»en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Refractive_index
Selenia

join:2006-09-22
Pittsfield, MA
·RoadRunner Cable


edit:
July 9th, @11:11AM

Re: love the FUD

said by odog See Profile :

»www.hometownutilicom.org/Service···net.html

quote:
Our Internet is second to none! Light vs. Copper! Did you know that light travels at a speed of 570 million miles per hour? Still think copper DSL and cable modems are fast enough?
Do they know thats a useless fact and that information actually travels slower through fiber than through copper(coax or twisted pair).

»en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Velocity_o···pagation
lol since when have ISP ads ever made intelligent claims(some of Time Warner's and Comcast's are just beautiful /sarcasm)? What really matters to us is that fiber can carry more bandwidth load(though many underestimate high quality coax). The velocity factor would be not perceptible by human beings, or even online games.

quote:
Our FTTH has built in "intelligence" to control the balance of Internet bandwidth
PS-Nice way of saying you use traffic shaping(although it's not always an evil thing, like some ISPs' implementations)?

aaronwt
Premium
join:2004-11-07
Woodbridge, VA
·Verizon FIOS
·Comcast
·Verizon Online DSL

said by odog See Profile :

»www.hometownutilicom.org/Service···net.html

quote:
Our Internet is second to none! Light vs. Copper! Did you know that light travels at a speed of 570 million miles per hour? Still think copper DSL and cable modems are fast enough?
Do they know thats a useless fact and that information actually travels slower through fiber than through copper(coax or twisted pair).

»en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Velocity_o···pagation
»en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Refractive_index
Where does that link show anything about the Velocity of Propagation in fiber?

odog
Cable Centric Vendor Biased
Premium
join:2001-08-05
Norcross, GA
clubs:

Re: love the FUD

second link about refractive index of light in a given medium.

chrisoverly

@mchsi.com

Give the company a break

Personally I would love a 3.0 upload speed, as the max I can get here is a 1.5 with SDSL that would cost me $250 a month, and even then it is not guaranteed.... and I pay $60 a month for 6 Mb down and 512 kbps up.... I would gladly pay $80 for a 3.0 upload speed... and sometimes smaller ISP's cannot afford
the backhauls for higher speeds, the big guys can because they have millions that float around doing nothing... perhaps that is why this company does not offer higher speeds... give the little guy a break, nobody even needs a 3.0 upload speed yet... and if you do you are more than likely running a server....
iansltx

join:2007-02-19
Fredericksburg, TX

Re: Give the company a break

Or uploading photos to a photo sharing site, in full-blown glory. Heck, even high quality JPEGS on a 7 megapixel camera take FOREVER to upload...on a T1-powered WiFi hotspot! I'd pay extra for 1, 2, 3 or 5 Mbit upload if I could get it.

dvd536
as Mr. Pink as they come
Premium
join:2001-04-27
Phoenix, AZ

Wake me up

2000/128 for $80 while subs on fios get 20000/20000 for $65.
Hmmmmmm. * y a w n *
--
When I gez aju zavateh na nalechoo more new yonooz tonigh molinigh - Ken Lee

slayerd59

@metrocast.net

Kutztown more than 500 residents

Kutztown may have only around 5,000 permanent residents but when college is in it soars to over 20,000. And those students want/need higher d/l and u/l than that.
Forums » Fiber To The Home In Kutztown, PA


Sunday, 23-Nov 04:43:03 Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Hosting by www.nac.net - DSL,Hosting & Co-lo | feedback | contact
over 9 years online! © 1999-2008 dslreports.com.republican-creole