Search:  

 
 
   News
newer
story category CRTC To Rule On Bell Throttling Tomorrow
Independent ISPs hold their breath...
(old news - 01:30PM Wednesday Nov 19 2008)
tags: competition · business · world · Bell Sympatico · TekSavvy Solutions Inc.
Tipped by fourboxers See Profile
After months of contentious debate, it looks like Canadian regulators are poised to finally rule on the dispute between Bell Canada and independent ISPs tomorrow. According to the CBC, the CRTC will issue their ruling tomorrow morning, after delaying their decision twice. Earlier this year, Bell Canada began throttling the traffic of wholesale competitors before delivering it to them, and without telling them. While Bell claimed the move was to handle congestion, follow up inquiries showed little to no congestion -- leading to the assumption that Bell simply didn't want any competitors offering DSL service that was superior to their own, throttled Sympatico service.

Related:
  1. Bell Canada Makes It Harder To Leave
  2. Indie Canadian ISPs Fight For Their Life
  3. CRTC Posts Private Data To Public Website
  4. Canadian Consumer Groups Slam CRTC
  5. Bell Canada Discontinuing Video Store
  6. Canada Holds Hearings On ISP Throttling
  7. Canadians Take Heed Of Harvard Broadband Study
  8. CRTC Blocks Canada's WIND Wireless Network
Forums » CRTC To Rule On Bell Throttling Tomorrow
view: topics flat text 
Post a:

damir
SFRJ
Premium
join:2003-05-24

he

finalllllllllyyyyy

Matt
Take me down to the paradise city
Premium
join:2003-07-20
Jamestown, NC

Other reasons

They also didn't want competition for their newly launched video service.

ptrowski
Got Helix?
Premium
join:2005-03-14
Putnam, CT
clubs:

Check is being delivered now....

I would imagine a sizable check from Bell is being delivered as we speak, or a few behind the scenes calls are being made.

I would love to think this will be a win for Rocky et all, but I fear the worst and hope for the best.

adisor19

join:2004-10-11

The moment of truth approaches yet again

We're about to find out if the government works for the pple or for the corporations.

Adi
mr_hexen

join:2007-08-02
Brampton, ON

Re: The moment of truth approaches yet again

said by adisor19 See Profile :

We're about to find out if the government works for the pple or for the corporations.

Adi
BINGO.
kyle747

join:2008-04-09
Orleans, ON

Re: The moment of truth approaches yet again

jeez I hate bad news

I'll be hoping for the best, but I am such a pessimist
dks7

join:2004-05-31

Re: The moment of truth approaches yet again

I am an American and am hoping for you guys as well. Damn corps screwing everyone these days.

Froggy

@bell.ca

Re: The moment of truth approaches yet again

You said it. At least we found out the FCC ruled throttling to be unAmerican but Canada is a socialist country bordering on communism. Thank you for still offering us dial-up from your country for one third the price of dial-up in Canada.
jj_frap

join:2003-12-15
·Bell Sympatico

Re: The moment of truth approaches yet again

What an ignorant statement! No socialist or social democrat, aside from a few right-wing sham parties in the "Socialist" International and that Hoxhaist party in Venezuela that engaged in political killing to assist the attempted right-wing coup against Chavez, would ever argue that consumer rights ought to sacrificed in the name of corporate profit and corporate control. Certain Stalinists and other authoritarians, who are about as representative of socialist and social democratic thought in Canada as Hitler is a representative of the Conservative Party, would advocate Internet censorship for very different reasons, but such ideological questions are not relevant when comparing the behaviour of regulatory bodies and the set of regulations they are mandated to enforce in two different mixed-economy states. When it comes to issues of sensible copyright law, consumer protection, and network neutrality, the NDP, along with certain factions of the Green Party, the BQ, and even *shudders* the Liberal Party, is far more favourable to the interests of the Canadian people than the neo-liberal interests that comprise the Conservative Party and the more rightist factions of the Liberal Party. Canada has the benefit of having a fairly vibrant social-democratic left that has not been corrupted by the interests of the elites in Hollywood and the entertainment industry, the same of which cannot be said of the United States, where everyone within 10 feet of the Democratic Party, Kucinich and Sanders excepted, is bought and sold by these crooks.
yac898

join:2002-12-06
Stony Plain, AB

Re: The moment of truth approaches yet again

huh? i recommend more fiber in your diet. anyway back to the real topic. i also hope for the best but fear the worst.
Pv8man

join:2008-07-24
Hammond, IN

Something tells me that this won't go easy.

I think we the people and also independent ISPs are going to be disappointed tomorrow.

With all the money that they have saved on NOT upgrading, that means they have plenty of money for Bribery (Lobbying)
Warez_Zealot
Rural land of the rising sun

join:2006-04-19
japan

said by kyle747 See Profile :

jeez I hate bad news

I'll be hoping for the best, but I am such a pessimist
Heh, just move to Japan. The internet is decent even in the country, and the women are easy.

You get the best of both worlds!

MarkAW
Barry White or lil bratt
Premium
join:2001-08-27
Canada
·Bell Sympatico
·Cogeco Cable

said by adisor19 See Profile :

We're about to find out if the government works for the pple or for the corporations.

Adi
On both sides of the border.

VaselinePlease

CRTC

We're boned.

KrK
Heavy Artillery For The Little Guy
Premium
join:2000-01-17
Tulsa, OK

Crosses fingers, Roots for Teksavvy etc

Hopes our neighbors to the North will have a fair chance at getting a decent ISP.

TKJunkMail
Enjoy the sun
Premium
join:2002-03-03
Avalon, NJ
·Sprint Mobile Broa..
·Comcast


2 edits

Regulatory agencies usually take path of least resistance

They will want to make both sides happy, which of course will make neither side happy. So expect the decision to come down somewhere in the middle.

Most likely outcome:
1 - CRTC says that Bell has to honor existing wholesale agreements and not throttle.
2 - Throttling will be OK as long as it isn't discriminatory. Sort of like what the FCC and Comcast came up with in the US.
3 - Bell will add throttling to any renewals of existing wholesale agreements and all NEW agreements.
--
My BLOG .. .. Internet News .. .. My Web Page
Ask yourself one question: 'Do I feel lucky?' Well, do ya punk?

en102
Canadian, eh?

join:2001-01-26
Valencia, CA

1 edit

Re: Regulatory agencies usually take path of least resistance

Very likely.
Item #3 will probably be with caps and/or tiered usage.
Expect price increases if anything.
--
Canada = Hollywood North

mlerner
Premium
join:2000-11-25
Nepean, ON
·Rogers Hi-Speed
·TekSavvy Solutions..
·Bell Sympatico

My understanding is this case only involves the current agreement and the only decision rendered will be whether Bell can apply throttling to wholesale. If there is going to be any changes to the wholesale tariff, it will have to be dealt with in a new case.

milnoc

join:2001-03-05
H2Z

Re: Regulatory agencies usually take path of least resistance

That's pretty much it. And the CRTC chairman has already indicated that a further investigation in current throttling practices will be initiated at a later date.
lrtc

join:2004-06-05
Toronto

hmmm

Can they go after rogers now?
LazMan

join:2003-03-26
Angus, ON
·TekSavvy Solutions..

Re: hmmm

said by lrtc See Profile :

Can they go after rogers now?
No. Roger's can do whatever they want to their own customers... This ruling only applies to wholesale customers. This ruling also won't impact Symptico clients, whom Bell can throttle at will.
jj_frap

join:2003-12-15
·Bell Sympatico

Re: hmmm

They could theoretically go after Rogers at a later date, but that would require a government that cares enough about civil liberties and about the interests of Canadian consumers to create a new regulatory framework to deal with the equitable provision of Internet services or to pass legislation to modify the scope of our existing regulatory frameworks. I know somebody of considerable charisma, intellect, and depth of issue knowledge who would be capable of getting elected and of leading such a government, but that would require Jack Layton's retirement and for the person in question to win leadership of the NDP. It's sad that I have to say this, because I like Jack quite a bit and believe that he has done great things for the NDP, but I think soon it will be time for a new leader.
LazMan

join:2003-03-26
Angus, ON
·TekSavvy Solutions..

Re: hmmm

On what grounds? The internet is not regulated as an essential service; each provider is free to treat their customers as they see fit.

The whole involvement of the CRTC here is strictly to interpret the tarrif, and if Bell has the right to throttle wholesale client's customers, prior to the traffic entering the wholesale client's network.

Anyways - I hope the CRTC makes a common-sense ruling here - but not holding my breath...

Laz

bellsucks

@sympatico.ca

I'm not getting my hopes up

After all, it is the CRTC we're talking about here.

JunkieXL

join:2004-11-15
Canada!

Re: I'm not getting my hopes up

I'm with you there, but hoping for the best.

fatness
subtle
Janitor
join:2000-11-17
fishing

denied

»www.crtc.gc.ca/eng/NEWS/RELEASES···1120.htm

Bender_2k

join:2003-01-12
clubs:

Re: denied

And of course...nothing changes...

Keith Mahar

@com.au

www.mediascam.com

I am a former corporate insider in the Canadian broadcasting industry. What is needed is a public review of the CRTC and democratic reform of the agency. Professor Matthew Fraser wrote in 2000 that the CRTC had been totally captured by industry interests by the late 1980s and is "cursed by institutionalized corruption." Fraser is correct, and the throttling issue is simply a by-product of the industry bias at the CRTC. Furthermore, there is evidence of potential illegal activities involving the CRTC and cable companies that my legal counsel advised PM Harper of and no action has been taken. If interested, check out www.mediascam.com, or Google Keith Mahar CRTC, or Keith Mahar crony capitalism. The main problem with the CRTC being corrupt is that the cabinet appointed bureaucrats are empowered to select which Canadians are permitted to own broadcasting companies, and exert influence over public opinion. The integrity of Canadian media has been undermined and corrupted by decisions made by the CRTC. The CRTC deserves to be 'throttled' and reformed in the public interest.
Forums » CRTC To Rule On Bell Throttling Tomorrow


Wednesday, 25-Nov 09:18:57 Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Hosting by www.nac.net - DSL,Hosting & Co-lo | feedback | contact
over 10 years online! © 1999-2009 dslreports.com.republican-creole