  TK Junk Mail Go ahead, make my day Premium join:2002-03-03 Margate City, NJ clubs:
·Comcast
edit: August 3rd, @12:14PM
| Porn industry threats backed by organized crime
Unlike the RIAA or the MPAA, the porn industry is backed by the Mafia and their threats to crack down on web sites breaking copyright carries some leg-breaking weight.
Even the threats of lawsuits hints at something darker:
“No one is immune,” he said. “The big problem I see right now is not outsiders doing this; rather, it is people who purport to be contributing members in our industry. As a result, we know who is doing this, we know where they are, we know where they process transactions, we know where they bank, we know where they host and we know where they live.
“This means when we come for you, we know how to get you. To the thieves that laugh about this, remember that we are coordinated. We are your affiliates, we are the guys you sit next to at industry dinners and the people that bump your posts on boards. Hiding is hard to do when we know what you look like, bro.” I'll bet they are more successful at getting compliance than the RIAA is. 
Tucker’s new target refers largely to the deluge of “tube” websites that have sprung up in the past few years: styled after the ever-so-popular YouTube, there are now hundreds of these sites offering free streaming video complete with search engines, indexed content, tagging, and in some cases even a download option. Much of their content, however, is pirated. And what are all these "porn tube" sites they were talking about. A google search provides this: »www.google.com/search?hl=en&ned=···+the+Web -- My BLOG .. .. Internet News .. .. My Web Page Ask yourself one question: 'Do I feel lucky?' Well, do ya punk? | |
|  |   Xizer
join:2004-02-05 New York, NY
| Re: Porn industry threats backed by organized crime said by TK Junk Mail :Unlike the RIAA or the MPAA, the porn industry is backed by the Mafia and their threats to crack down on web sites breaking copyright carries some leg-breaking weight. Oooh, scary!! Not. The Mafia are a bunch of pussies these days. They can't accomplish shit and it would be foolish to be afraid of them. | |
|  |  |   BeesTea Network Janitor Premium,VIP join:2003-03-08 00000
| Re: Porn industry threats backed by organized crime said by Xizer :Oooh, scary!! Not. The Mafia are a bunch of pussies these days. They can't accomplish shit and it would be foolish to be afraid of them. You're posting from Kenosha, WI. You're going to post authoritatively about the mob? Seriously?
That's pretty funny. -- Overpower, overcome. | |
|  |  |  |   Xizer
join:2004-02-05 New York, NY
| Re: Porn industry threats backed by organized crime said by BeesTea :said by Xizer :Oooh, scary!! Not. The Mafia are a bunch of pussies these days. They can't accomplish shit and it would be foolish to be afraid of them. You're posting from Kenosha, WI. You're going to post authoritatively about the mob? Seriously? That's pretty funny. Kenosha is a Chicago suburb. | |
|  |  |  |  |   BeesTea Network Janitor Premium,VIP join:2003-03-08 00000 | Re: Porn industry threats backed by organized crime I live in Chicago, I know where Kenosha is. There's no more organized crime in Kenosha than there is in Portage Indiana, your opposing distant end of fringe "Chicagoland". -- Overpower, overcome. | |
|  |  |  |  |  |   Xizer
join:2004-02-05 New York, NY
| Re: Porn industry threats backed by organized crime said by BeesTea :I live in Chicago, I know where Kenosha is. There's no more organized crime in Kenosha than there is in Portage Indiana, your opposing distant end of fringe "Chicagoland". OH NO THE MOB IS WATCHING ME OVER THE INTERNETS | |
|  |  |  |  |  |  |   TK Junk Mail Go ahead, make my day Premium join:2002-03-03 Margate City, NJ clubs:
·Comcast
| Re: Porn industry threats backed by organized crime said by Xizer :said by BeesTea :I live in Chicago, I know where Kenosha is. There's no more organized crime in Kenosha than there is in Portage Indiana, your opposing distant end of fringe "Chicagoland". OH NO THE MOB IS WATCHING ME OVER THE INTERNETS As a porn viewer, you have nothing to worry about. It is the owner of the porn web sites abusing copyright that should worry, as has been obvious from the 1st post. What you are throwing up claiming you are not worried is a "Straw man argument" since you were never the target. -- My BLOG .. .. Internet News .. .. My Web Page Ask yourself one question: 'Do I feel lucky?' Well, do ya punk? | |
|  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |   Bink63 Cubs NL Central Division Champs Premium join:2002-10-06 Everywhere
| said by BeesTea :said by Xizer :Oooh, scary!! Not. The Mafia are a bunch of pussies these days. They can't accomplish shit and it would be foolish to be afraid of them. You're posting from Kenosha, WI. You're going to post authoritatively about the mob? Seriously? That's pretty funny. Actually, The Oufit has always owned a huge chunk of the border counties...
Kenosha/Pleasant Prairie, Bristol and Trevor all have had and DO have huge amounts of properties owned by them.
And Lake County, IL...
how do you think controlled substances make their way down to the city????
Chain Of Lakes anyone?
Oh, and Xizer...
Kenosha isn't a suburb of Chicago, it's a suburb of Racine!  -- »www.otadigitaltv.com Frank Shoemaker would call this noise | |
|  |  |  |  |   Xizer
join:2004-02-05 New York, NY
| Re: Porn industry threats backed by organized crime said by Bink63 :Kenosha isn't a suburb of Chicago, it's a suburb of Racine! You guys lost your big city status ages ago. 100,000 population vs. 80,000 population... Racine is a suburb of Kenosha now. | |
|  |  cool_coda
join:2004-09-08 Brownsburg, IN | So are they only going after video sites?
Hope my dear beloved boxtheclown.com doesn't get taken down. What do you do without free porn? | |
|  |  |   dadkins Go For It Premium,MVM join:2003-09-26 Hercules, CA
·Comcast
edit: August 3rd, @12:01PM
| Please! "Pirated", "stolen", "thieves"...
When someone is seen/caught raping and killing someone then stealing their media, then we can call them a "pirate".
If one copies a movie, the original is still in the possession of it's owner - nothing was "stolen"
Until someone actually goes into BlockBuster and walks out with a disc or discs, they are not a thief.
Call them what they are - "Copyright Infringers". Not as dramatic, is it? 
Pretty soon, borrowing a DVD will be considered illegal/stealing/piracy.  What then?
How about, only YOU can watch YOUR DVDs. I have a stack of discs. You come over for a visit. You see a disc or three that you would like to watch. Out of fear of prosecution or lawsuit, I refuse too allow you.
You did not pay for it, you are stealing if you view a movie without paying for it!!!1
-- Think outside the Fox... Opera | |
|  |  ja2007123
join:2007-10-06
·AT&T Southeast
·Dish Network
| Re: Please! Copying without the authorization of the author is illegal don't you think. If I go to blockbuster, and I take a laptop, I can make a copy of the dvd and that would be stupid and illegal.
So my point, it doesn't matter if the original is in possession of its owner, you are making a copy WITHOUTH authorization. | |
|  |  |   dadkins Go For It Premium,MVM join:2003-09-26 Hercules, CA
·Comcast
edit: August 3rd, @12:31PM
| Re: Please! said by ja2007123 :Copying without the authorization of the author is illegal don't you think. If I go to blockbuster, and I take a laptop, I can make a copy of the dvd and that would be stupid and illegal. So my point, it doesn't matter if the original is in possession of its owner, you are making a copy WITHOUTH authorization. There is no theft! No one stole anything.
It is Copyright Infringement at best! Nothing more!
Bring your scenario to my house. Grab________ DVD or Blu-ray. Knock yourself out! Now what? I paid money for my discs. If you ask me, I have no problem with you having a copy - of any media I own. CDs DVDs Blu-rays Games Applications Insert data here ___________
Since I allowed you access to my library, you did not steal anything... did you?
You are not a pirate, you are not a thief. Even if you were to look at it from the point of view of the author - it is not theft! *I* would never call you a thief - you didn't steal anything! You copied it!
All my childhood growing up I was always told to share... Want one? 
EDIT: Got VCR? Got DVR? Do you know what they do? They copy. Does that also make you a thief?
I have the whole 1st season of Robot Chicken on one of my HDDs - part of season 2. Did I "Steal" them?  -- Think outside the Fox... Opera | |
|  |  |  |  ja2007123
join:2007-10-06 | Re: Please! Yeah sharing is not illegal. But sharing a "copy" is illegal. When you share your stuff, let say your dvds, you are sharing the actual cds and that's completely legal. But sharing files is diffrent, you are making copies and sharing. | |
|  |  |  |  |   dadkins Go For It Premium,MVM join:2003-09-26 Hercules, CA
·Comcast
edit: August 3rd, @12:50PM
| Re: Please! said by ja2007123 :Yeah sharing is not illegal. But sharing a "copy" is illegal. When you share your stuff, let say your dvds, you are sharing the actual cds and that's completely legal. But sharing files is diffrent, you are making copies and sharing. Wrong! If I hand you a disc, what you do with it is your business. Watch it, copy it, convert it for your iPod - whatever! I have no problem with this! Hand me your iPod and the cord, I'll fill that bugger up! 
Tell me, when you COPY HBO or Showtime on your DVR... is that stealing too? How about LOST? When you COPY LOST on the ole DVR... doesn't that make you a thief? 
You must excuse me now, I going to go watch some "illegal & stolen" porn.  -- Think outside the Fox... Opera | |
|  |  |  |   captain456
@gci.com
moderated: August 3rd, @02:34PM
| said by dadkins :said by ja2007123 :Copying without the authorization of the author is illegal don't you think. If I go to blockbuster, and I take a laptop, I can make a copy of the dvd and that would be stupid and illegal. So my point, it doesn't matter if the original is in possession of its owner, you are making a copy WITHOUTH authorization. There is no theft! No one stole anything. It is Copyright Infringement at best! Nothing more! Bring your scenario to my house. Grab________ DVD or Blu-ray. Knock yourself out! Now what? I paid money for my discs. If you ask me, I have no problem with you having a copy - of any media I own. CDs DVDs Blu-rays Games Applications Insert data here ___________ Since I allowed you access to my library, you did not steal anything... did you? You are not a pirate, you are not a thief. Even if you were to look at it from the point of view of the author - it is not theft! *I* would never call you a thief - you didn't steal anything! You copied it! All my childhood growing up I was always told to share... Want one?  EDIT: Got VCR? Got DVR? Do you know what they do? They copy. Does that also make you a thief? I have the whole 1st season of Robot Chicken on one of my HDDs - part of season 2. Did I "Steal" them? Yes it is theft. Do you not understand that you do NOT OWN THE MOVIE even if you buy the DVD? You own the physical dvd and that is all. You DO NOT own the content on the DVD. All you bought was the privalige (or in softwares case lisence) to watch the movie. It's not yours to share with even your friends. by doing so you are STEALING the content on the DVD. and no I'm not in the industry and yes I've done the same thing myself I just am man enough to admit it is not right and I don't have to lie to myself and others to sleep at night. | |
|  |  |  |  |  SauceMaster
join:2004-08-01 Kokomo, IN
·AT&T Midwest
·Vonage
| Re: Please! said by captain456 :said by dadkins :said by ja2007123 :Copying without the authorization of the author is illegal don't you think. If I go to blockbuster, and I take a laptop, I can make a copy of the dvd and that would be stupid and illegal. So my point, it doesn't matter if the original is in possession of its owner, you are making a copy WITHOUTH authorization. There is no theft! No one stole anything. It is Copyright Infringement at best! Nothing more! Bring your scenario to my house. Grab________ DVD or Blu-ray. Knock yourself out! Now what? I paid money for my discs. If you ask me, I have no problem with you having a copy - of any media I own. CDs DVDs Blu-rays Games Applications Insert data here ___________ Since I allowed you access to my library, you did not steal anything... did you? You are not a pirate, you are not a thief. Even if you were to look at it from the point of view of the author - it is not theft! *I* would never call you a thief - you didn't steal anything! You copied it! All my childhood growing up I was always told to share... Want one?  EDIT: Got VCR? Got DVR? Do you know what they do? They copy. Does that also make you a thief? I have the whole 1st season of Robot Chicken on one of my HDDs - part of season 2. Did I "Steal" them? no I'm not in the industry and yes I've done the same thing myself I just am man enough to admit it is not right and I don't have to lie to myself and others to sleep at night. Sounds like the pot , calling the kettle black. You are trying to preach the good word ..in the end you admit to doing the same.
So what makes you any better to say what someone is ? Maybe you should practice what you are preaching ? -- Broadcasting The Classic Rock Hits 24/7 SauceMaster Radio!!!! | |
|  |  |  |  |  |   captain456
@gci.com
| Re: Please! said by SauceMaster :Sounds like the pot , calling the kettle black. You are trying to preach the good word ..in the end you admit to doing the same. So what makes you any better to say what someone is ? Maybe you should practice what you are preaching ? Maybe you misread or have a problem comprehending. I'm not preaching they shouldn't share copyrighted material. Frankly I don't care. I'm just making the point that it is illegal and they are stupid for not understanding that. I know it is illegal and if I get caught it will be my own damn fault. (with that said I don't listen to music at all so I don't download anything anyway so I don't worry about getting caught. I just meant that I have occasionally in the past years) | |
|  |  |  |  |   punker deleted by moderator Premium join:2004-06-21 Palmdale, CA clubs:
·Time Warner Cable
·Time Warner VOIP
·RoadRunner Cable
| said by captain456 :said by dadkins :said by ja2007123 :Copying without the authorization of the author is illegal don't you think. If I go to blockbuster, and I take a laptop, I can make a copy of the dvd and that would be stupid and illegal. So my point, it doesn't matter if the original is in possession of its owner, you are making a copy WITHOUTH authorization. There is no theft! No one stole anything. It is Copyright Infringement at best! Nothing more! Bring your scenario to my house. Grab________ DVD or Blu-ray. Knock yourself out! Now what? I paid money for my discs. If you ask me, I have no problem with you having a copy - of any media I own. CDs DVDs Blu-rays Games Applications Insert data here ___________ Since I allowed you access to my library, you did not steal anything... did you? You are not a pirate, you are not a thief. Even if you were to look at it from the point of view of the author - it is not theft! *I* would never call you a thief - you didn't steal anything! You copied it! All my childhood growing up I was always told to share... Want one?  EDIT: Got VCR? Got DVR? Do you know what they do? They copy. Does that also make you a thief? I have the whole 1st season of Robot Chicken on one of my HDDs - part of season 2. Did I "Steal" them? Yes it is theft. Do you not understand that you do NOT OWN THE MOVIE even if you buy the DVD? You own the physical dvd and that is all. You DO NOT own the content on the DVD. All you bought was the privalige (or in softwares case lisence) to watch the movie. It's not yours to share with even your friends. by doing so you are STEALING the content on the DVD. and no I'm not in the industry and yes I've done the same thing myself I just am man enough to admit it is not right and I don't have to lie to myself and others to sleep at night. sony says:
OWN it today on dvd | |
|  |  |  |   captain456
@gci.com
| said by dadkins :said by ja2007123 :Copying without the authorization of the author is illegal don't you think. If I go to blockbuster, and I take a laptop, I can make a copy of the dvd and that would be stupid and illegal. So my point, it doesn't matter if the original is in possession of its owner, you are making a copy WITHOUTH authorization. There is no theft! No one stole anything. It is Copyright Infringement at best! Nothing more! Bring your scenario to my house. Grab________ DVD or Blu-ray. Knock yourself out! Now what? I paid money for my discs. If you ask me, I have no problem with you having a copy - of any media I own. CDs DVDs Blu-rays Games Applications Insert data here ___________ Since I allowed you access to my library, you did not steal anything... did you? You are not a pirate, you are not a thief. Even if you were to look at it from the point of view of the author - it is not theft! *I* would never call you a thief - you didn't steal anything! You copied it! All my childhood growing up I was always told to share... Want one?  EDIT: Got VCR? Got DVR? Do you know what they do? They copy. Does that also make you a thief? I have the whole 1st season of Robot Chicken on one of my HDDs - part of season 2. Did I "Steal" them? Yes, you are a theif, and yes what you are saying here is stealing. This is not debatable. spend 5 minutes looking at the the legal precedants. Thers no debate you a theif and theres no way around it other than to stop stealing. Stop being a coward and justify your stealing so you can sleep at night. | |
|  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |   captain456
@gci.com
| Re: Please! said by dadkins :So, every time YOU record something to your DVR, YOU are stealing too? Admitting it is the first step! I have 3 laptops that are DVRs. At least one will be recording something at night... usually. Bad Bad thief, huh? Recording TV is not stealing - look it up!  BTW, joining DSLReports is free. No, that's not what I said. Do you have a reading comprehension problem? | |
|  |  |  |  |  |  |   dadkins Go For It Premium,MVM join:2003-09-26 Hercules, CA
·Comcast
| Re: Please! Absolutely not, but it appears you do. I asked a question about recording Robot Chicken being illegal or stealing, you said it was. WTF?

Is that you Taylor?
BTW, it's thief, not theif - and it is not stealing! This was settled years ago - Sony vs Universal aka the Betamax case.
Welcome to 1984 -- Think outside the Fox... Opera | |
|  |  |  karlmarx
join:2006-09-18 Nashua, NH
·Fairpoint Communic..
| But, umm, that's EXACTLY what I did. I got a blockbuster pass, a very nice notebook, a 500GB external hard drive. On Sat Morning, I would go in and get 2 movies, sit in my car, rip them (about 10 minutes to copy each DVD), and then walk in, trade back my movies, and repeat, ALL DAY LONG. Guess what, what I did was PERFECTLY LEGAL. I was choosing to space/time shift the content I LEGALLY ACQUIRED! I didn't 'pirate' the movies, I rented them. In about 8 hours, I copied about 50 movies every saturday. If you listen to the **ASSASSes, what I did was illegal. But, it's NOT. I PAID FOR THE MOVIE. I GET TO WATCH IT WHEN I WANT TO.
Look at it this way. What are you 'getting' when you rent a movie? Are you getting the media? If so, then I have the media, and I can do what I want to with it. The fact that it's media, and I RETURNED it, that's not theft.
Are you renting the 'right to watch it'. Well, that's what I'm doing too! I'm watching it, just not on their terms. If I sat in my car, and ran the DVD at 20x speed to watch it, would I be breaking the law? That's exactly what I did, I just chose to watch it at regular speed at a later date.
In any case, the manager knew exactly what I was doing, and he DIDN'T CARE. Not...even...a....little. -- The happiest countries are the most secular. The struggle AGAINST corporations is the struggle FOR humanity! | |
|  |  |  |   jjoshua Premium join:2001-06-01 Scotch Plains, NJ | Re: Please! Except that you're not the owner of the media when you rent it.
You paid to rent the movie and you're entitled to watch it during the rental period. When you return the disk, you're done. | |
|  |  |  |  |  karlmarx
join:2006-09-18 Nashua, NH
·Fairpoint Communic..
| Re: Please! So, using your logic, DVR's are illegal too? I mean, I'm entitled to watch the show when it's broadcast, but if I record it, I don't have the right to watch it later? Please enlighten me. I rented it, I watched it. What if I brought it home and recorded it on my DVR, would that be stealing too? I mean, my DVR can record a movie from HBO for later watching, and the DVR is no different than a specialized computer. The fact of the matter is I paid for HBO, and I have the RIGHT TO TIME SHIFT, and the RIGHT TO SPACE SHIFT (see betamax case), so how is what I'm doing any different? I PAID for the rental. What if I deleted the movie after i watched it on my computer, would that make it ok? (umm, yeah, I'll do that). -- The happiest countries are the most secular. The struggle AGAINST corporations is the struggle FOR humanity! | |
|  |  |  |  |  |   jjoshua Premium join:2001-06-01 Scotch Plains, NJ | Re: Please! You are allowed to record broadcasts and watch whenever you want. You cannot record rented movies to watch whenever you want.
A 5 year old can understand the concept. | |
|  |  |  |  |  |  |  ssokolow
join:2008-03-23
·TekSavvy Solutions..
·Bell Sympatico
| Re: Please! Well, I don't. Aside from the DMCA DRM circumvention bit (which is meaningless outside of the U.S.), I see no difference between copying off broadcast and copying off a rented DVD.
What next? A law prohibiting copying of movie data tattooed onto a plucked chicken? | |
|  |  |  |  |  |  |  karlmarx
join:2006-09-18 Nashua, NH
·Fairpoint Communic..
| Please explain the difference? I mean, I get HBO, am I allowed to record movies from that? I'm PAYING for HBO, and the movies are exactly the same as the DVD I'm renting. Again, apart from the DMCA, which I don't follow, please explain the difference? The only difference I see is the convenience for me. It's more convenient for me to copy it from a DVD than it is for me to record the exact same thing from HBO. So you're telling me, that the law states I can't place/time shift the media, I LEGALLY ACQUIRED, to a different device, so I can watch it on my own schedule? Please, stop drinking the **AA kool-aid. The fact that I don't CHOOSE to watch it on their terms, does not mean that I give up all rights to watch it. I PAID THEM MONEY for the product, how I use that product is up to ME. I don't give up my rights just because 'they say' I give up my rights. -- The happiest countries are the most secular. The struggle AGAINST corporations is the struggle FOR humanity! | |
|  |  |  |  |  |  |  |   jjoshua Premium join:2001-06-01 Scotch Plains, NJ
·Comcast
| Re: Please! So you're saying that if you rent the movie, you should have the same "rights" to watch the movie as someone who actually purchased the move?
Why not just make a few extra copies and give them to your friends... You could say that you are place shifting your movie so you could watch it at your friends house whenever you want to time shift it over there.
When you rent, you haven't acquired anything. Again, a 5 year old can grasp this concept. | |
|  |  |  |   captain456
@gci.com
| said by karlmarx :But, umm, that's EXACTLY what I did. I got a blockbuster pass, a very nice notebook, a 500GB external hard drive. On Sat Morning, I would go in and get 2 movies, sit in my car, rip them (about 10 minutes to copy each DVD), and then walk in, trade back my movies, and repeat, ALL DAY LONG. Guess what, what I did was PERFECTLY LEGAL. I was choosing to space/time shift the content I LEGALLY ACQUIRED! I didn't 'pirate' the movies, I rented them. In about 8 hours, I copied about 50 movies every saturday. If you listen to the **ASSASSes, what I did was illegal. But, it's NOT. I PAID FOR THE MOVIE. I GET TO WATCH IT WHEN I WANT TO. Look at it this way. What are you 'getting' when you rent a movie? Are you getting the media? If so, then I have the media, and I can do what I want to with it. The fact that it's media, and I RETURNED it, that's not theft. Are you renting the 'right to watch it'. Well, that's what I'm doing too! I'm watching it, just not on their terms. If I sat in my car, and ran the DVD at 20x speed to watch it, would I be breaking the law? That's exactly what I did, I just chose to watch it at regular speed at a later date. In any case, the manager knew exactly what I was doing, and he DIDN'T CARE. Not...even...a....little. IF you are copying them and you are the only person watching them than that is fine. If you give a copy to your friend that is the crime. Also what the manager at blocker says is irrelevant. If I tell you it's ok to steal someone elses property that doesn't make it ok. | |
|  |  |  |  |  See 9 replies to this post | |
 |   Jovi
join:2000-02-24 Mount Joy, PA
| said by dadkins :"Pirated", "stolen", "thieves"... When someone is seen/caught raping and killing someone then stealing their media, then we can call them a "pirate". If one copies a movie, the original is still in the possession of it's owner - nothing was "stolen" Until someone actually goes into BlockBuster and walks out with a disc or discs, they are not a thief. Call them what they are - "Copyright Infringers". Not as dramatic, is it?  Pretty soon, borrowing a DVD will be considered illegal/stealing/piracy.  What then? How about, only YOU can watch YOUR DVDs. I have a stack of discs. You come over for a visit. You see a disc or three that you would like to watch. Out of fear of prosecution or lawsuit, I refuse too allow you. You did not pay for it, you are stealing if you view a movie without paying for it!!!1 Soon watching a movie at a friends house or accidentally hearing the cars radio next to you at a stop light will get you jail time. Walking into a Best Buy or Circuit City and checking out that new HD tv might get you a fine if you happen not to have a license to view the content playing on said tv. -- "Where's my coffee? Oh. I guess it's my turn to make it."  | |
|  |  |   dadkins Go For It Premium,MVM join:2003-09-26 Hercules, CA | Re: Please! Exactly! Whistle a tune, go to jail!  | |
|  |   meh37
@verizon.net
from: halfband 
| "Fair use" says that if you own the media (CD, DVD, whatever) containing some copyrighted material (music, movie, whatever), then you can legally copy it to other media for your own personal use, not for someone else's personal use: making a copy for yourself is OK, making a copy for someone else is not and neither is loaning someone else a copy you made for yourself. You could loan someone the original under the presumption that they aren't going to copy it, but is that something you can really rely on? Legally, "copyright infringement" is "theft", or as most people like to call it these days, "piracy".
The same "rule" applies to media you rent (from Blockbuster, Netflix, whomever): you aren't the owner of the media, so copying it is illegal. You've purchased the right to watch some movie only during the rental period (according to the contract between you and whomever you rented it from). If some copyright owners get their way, then eventually a large number of them will try to making recording TV an infringement of their copyright, too... talk about silly.
Now, do I care? Not even a little bit. The RIAA for more than a decade, and now the MPAA, are treating everyone like they're criminals for every little thing they do: DRM everything and DMCA everyone. The copyright laws in this country have been thrown so far out of whack by Congress that they're ridiculous. So as far as I'm concerned, it doesn't bother me in the least if someone or everyone steals everything they can get their hands on. Personally, I don't consider much of anything being produced these days worth my time or money to listen to or watch, let alone buy; but those few things I do want to own and keep, I will buy. Everything else is trash, and I'm quite alright with other people stealing as much trash as they want.
But don't fool yourself with semantics: taking what isn't yours is stealing. If the owner of something didn't give it to you, then it isn't yours. | |
|  |  |  See 12 replies to this post | |
 |   pog Premium join:2004-06-03 Kihei, HI
·Hawaiian Telcom
| Interesting that the article is _not_ about filesharing, per se. More about site operators _directly_ using stolen content as part of their business model.
Anyway, regarding "Pirated", "stolen", "thieves"...
Your whole point hinges on whether or not intangible property is property in the first place. »en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intangible_property If it is property, then violating the law in acquiring it would make one a pirate, thief, stealer, wouldn't it?
IMO, the real issue is whether or not certain means of acquiring (or duplicating for archival purposes) should be considered illegal. -- My Site | |
|  |  |   Jafo232 You Can't Spell Democrat Without Rat. Premium join:2002-10-17 Boonville, NY
| Re: Please! I have surely viewed/listened/installed my fair share of stuff over the years that I did not buy. It is downright theft. The idea that you can "share" a song with someone legally is bogus.
Let's call it what it is, theft. Honestly, this argument about it is only one thing: Guilty people trying to somehow justify their theft so they don't feel like thieves.
Now the recording industry is basically FUBAR. They "shared" their content over the radio for so many years, it is just second nature for people to not even consider it property, but look at it this way:
I come out with an album next month and here are some of my songs that my band and I cut on it:
Stairway To Heaven
Free Bird
For Whom the Bell Tolls
Who Let the Dogs Out
Jump Around
Like a Rhinestone Cowboy
All #1 songs at one point released by other artists. Using some peoples logic here, I don't need permission, nor pay royalties to the original artist because I bought the respective CD's and I now OWN the music and can do ANYTHING I want with it.
I bet if I did this, some of these same people would roll their eyes and be like "WTF, these guys totally ripped this song from Led Zeppelin, Lynard Skynard, etc.." Yet using the excuses in here as precedent, I should be able to do this. Obviously this is wrong.
I understand the need for piracy. How someone can make it in the graphics business these days paying thousands of dollars for a plethora of software is mind boggling. So when someone uses a pirated copy of photoshop, I definitely understand why, but it doesn't change the fact, the person is a thief. -- Custom PHP/Perl Development. Vbulletin And Wordpress Mods Too! | |
|  |  |  |   dadkins Go For It Premium,MVM join:2003-09-26 Hercules, CA
·Comcast
edit: August 3rd, @11:35PM
| Re: Please! I have "shared" music with my entire block before - my last car had (roughly) 1260 WATTS RMS @ 0.5% THD.
Music? Ever hear about Internet Radio? Ever hear about recording software? Many of us have, and recording music is not illegal. 
Music is so unimportant - to me at least. Movies, well, I am a member at a site where I can rent movies for next to nothing(less than $1.00).
So, all this posturing about theft and stealing is rather pointless. Copying, no matter what anyone tries to say, is not "stealing", period.
Some of you are... funny.  You go right ahead and keep telling yourselves that copying is theft/stealing/piracy.  If it makes you happy, I'm ok with it!
Now, I have to add a few items to my ORB page - see ya!  -- Think outside the Fox... Opera | |
|  |  |  |  |   Jafo232 You Can't Spell Democrat Without Rat. Premium join:2002-10-17 Boonville, NY
| Re: Please! said by dadkins :I have "shared" music with my entire block before - my last car had (roughly) 1260 WATTS RMS @ 0.5% THD. Music? Ever hear about Internet Radio? Ever hear about recording software? Many of us have, and recording music is not illegal.  Music is so unimportant - to me at least. Movies, well, I am a member at a site where I can rent movies for next to nothing(less than $1.00). So, all this posturing about theft and stealing is rather pointless. Copying, no matter what anyone tries to say, is not "stealing", period. Some of you are... funny.  You go right ahead and keep telling yourselves that copying is theft/stealing/piracy.  If it makes you happy, I'm ok with it! Now, I have to add a few items to my ORB page - see ya! Have you ever heard of slim jim? Since they make them, I can use it to take your car and "share" it with all my friends.
Ever heard of Hertz or RentaCar? Since they let you use the car, you must have the right to keep it, and share it with whomever you wish I guess.
Honestly, your analogy about recording music is like me saying to a cop that I have a drivers license so it was OK for me to take any car I want.
You can muddy up the issue all you want by saying listening to music with friends is the same as making a copy of said music and giving it to them (or whoever) but you are just fooling yourself.
-- Custom PHP/Perl Development. Vbulletin And Wordpress Mods Too! | |
| |
|