Search:  

 
 
   News
newer
story category Verizon Tops Consumer Reports Wireless Satisfaction Ratings
As consumers in general become less annoyed with their cell phone providers....
01:24PM Tuesday Dec 02 2008 by Karl Bode
tags: competition · business · wireless · consumers · Verizon Wireless Broadband · Cingular Wireless · T-Mobile US
The Consumer Reports National Research Center recently surveyed 51,700 readers in 23 cities to determine how satisfied users were with their cell phone service. Verizon Wireless took the top place for most satisfied customers, only beaten in a few locations by Alltel, which they'll be acquiring shortly. The findings indicate that 60% of people said they were "completely or very satisfied" with their service, up from 45% last year. Consumer Reports tells Mercury News a big reason for this is the new trend in making early termination fees less obnoxious:
Jeff Blyskal, senior editor of Consumer Reports, said telecommunications carriers have become more consumer friendly as a result of a vigorous campaign against practices like hefty early-termination fees and mandatory contract extensions. That campaign was led by public-interest lawyers who filed more than a hundred class-action lawsuits and politicians who proposed legislation in Congress that would have regulated fees and required wireless service providers to disclose information about dropped calls and gaps in service.
The worst performing carrier was Sprint-Nextel, who in addition to suffering from their botched acquisition of Nextel, is the last carrier to migrate to a pro-rated ETF system. They're apparently afraid that customers will take the opportunity to flee, which would be problematic given the carrier lost almost 2.5 million wireless subscribers in the last two quarters. For reference, Verizon added 2.1 million total (including acquisitions) last quarter alone.

AT&T didn't fare particularly well in the ratings, either. An AT&T spokesman tells Mercury News their poor ratings are because the Consumer Reports study is "based on anecdotal feedback from a self-selected group of subscribers," even though similar studies by firms like JD Power rank AT&T as mediocre to poor in everything from call quality to customer care. It looks like the full version of the Consumer Reports article is hidden behind a pay wall, but you can find additional coverage of the report at The Street and PC World.

Related:
  1. Product Spotlight: EV-DO Showdown - Verizon vs. Sprint
  2. Freeing The Phone From The ISP
  3. Wireless Carriers Step It Up In Response To Fires
  4. Cellphone Buying Increasingly Annoying
  5. Which 3G Network is the Best?
  6. Gizmodo Tests Nation's 3G Networks
  7. Verizon Acquisition of Alltel Closes January 9
  8. Verizon's Open Development Initiative? So Far It's A Joke
Forums » Verizon Tops Consumer Reports Wireless Satisfaction Ratings
view: topics flat text 
Post a:

Phil
Rojo Sol
Premium
join:2001-06-11
Camarillo, CA

One exception...

...Ventura County, California. Verizon has very poor coverage in Ventura County. No service and dropped calls.

en102
Canadian, eh?

join:2001-01-26
Valencia, CA
·RoadRunner Cable
·DSL EXTREME
·DSL EXTREME

AT&T didn't do well because...

They have a botched 3G network in many places.
Eg. Southern California, they have deployed 1/4 of their spectrum for 3G services on 1900MHz (while 850MHz would do a better coverage job).
This resulted in many seeing low signal (3G iPhone) and many dropped calls on 3G devices (how much voice + data can you push over a single 5MHz carrier in an area like Los Angeles?).

They've finally started deploying a 2nd 3G carrier on 850 MHz around here, and guess what... my 3G dropped calls have effectively stopped, and the browser now works.

AT&T CS Reps blame the phone or SIM card on every issue (they aren't technical... just first line of defense)
I did warranty exchange 3x with no fix.

HappyBunny
Hi. Cram It.
Premium
join:2001-06-23
Long Beach, CA
·Charter Pipeline

Re: AT&T didn't do well because...

said by en102 See Profile :

They have a botched 3G network in many places.
Eg. Southern California, they have deployed 1/4 of their spectrum for 3G services on 1900MHz (while 850MHz would do a better coverage job).
This resulted in many seeing low signal (3G iPhone) and many dropped calls on 3G devices (how much voice + data can you push over a single 5MHz carrier in an area like Los Angeles?).
Well why should that be a surprise? I was a customer when Cingular (now AT&T) rolled out the 850 band in LA and it was an utter disaster. Constant dropped calls, calls that were misrouted and calls that went silent on one end. Th Long Beach area was so bad I was able to terminate my contract early and go to the carrier ranked number two in this survey, T-Mobile. I love them, the service is excellent. Why Apple didn't choose them for the iPhone is beyond me

en102
Canadian, eh?

join:2001-01-26
Valencia, CA
·RoadRunner Cable
·DSL EXTREME
·DSL EXTREME

Re: AT&T didn't do well because...

Yup - I remember your posts on HoFo as well
Moving from T-Mobiles very well built/mature GSM 1900 only network to the former AT&T Wireless GSM/TDMA/AMPS network which had extensive use of AMR half rate was bad.
I was one of the lucky few with a Motorola seem edited phone for AMR-Full rate.
I'd be picking a G1 if I could get my corp discounts on T-Mo.

HappyBunny
Hi. Cram It.
Premium
join:2001-06-23
Long Beach, CA

Re: AT&T didn't do well because...

I remember you as well! I no longer have the Razer as my main phone... I am loving my new Sony Ericsson TM506 (in green!) It is a really good phone!

en102
Canadian, eh?

join:2001-01-26
Valencia, CA
·RoadRunner Cable
·DSL EXTREME
·DSL EXTREME


edit:
December 2nd, @07:11PM

Re: AT&T didn't do well because...

I'm a hold out for a decent device (attempting to have work replace my Blackberry 7100i Nextel - yuck for something better... probably iPAQ 910.
My current 'sacrifice' might be a tilt (purchase for $99 - 1 year contract ) - I just don't like the screen.
I'd probably have a G1 on T-Mobile by now if it has a remote desktop client. It has SSH client (needed for me)
and nearly same screen size (3.2" vs 3.5" for iPhone) and same resolution - 320x480 (tilt = 240x320 )
Many newer devices are 640x480, but small 2.8" viewable.
Pictures will look sharp, but difficult size for SSH client.

KrK
Heavy Artillery For The Little Guy
Premium
join:2000-01-17
Tulsa, OK

AT&T Blames the customer;

For being not satisfied with the service...

Are we surprised....
pabster

join:2001-12-09
Waterloo, IA

Corporate Reports?

Consumer Reports is bought and paid for. Anyone who trusts them for much more than toilet paper...

Not that AT&T has anything to brag about overall but if Verizon is really "tops" the U.S. Wireless industry is indeed in dismal shape.
clickie

join:2005-05-22
Monroe, MI

Re: Corporate Reports?

Really? Is that why they don't accept advertising in their print magazine? Furthermore, this was a survey of their members. They are just reporting what their readers said.

Listen, you really should acquaint yourself with Google and read up on things before you post. Then you would have found this about CU:

"Like the rest of Consumers Union, the Research Center is free of corporate influence and advertising. Its surveys are not commissioned or funded by industry, government, academia or big media. Rather, these surveys are designed to gather unbiased, objective information from consumers for the sole purpose of informing and protecting them.
"
pabster

join:2001-12-09
Waterloo, IA

Re: Corporate Reports?

Who needs advertising? Cash under the table is far more effective. If anyone believes Consumer Reports is truly OBJECTIVE and UNBIASED I have some terrific land deals for you...

TK Junk Mail
Go ahead, make my day
Premium
join:2002-03-03
Margate City, NJ
clubs:
·Comcast

Re: Corporate Reports?

said by pabster See Profile :

Who needs advertising? Cash under the table is far more effective. If anyone believes Consumer Reports is truly OBJECTIVE and UNBIASED I have some terrific land deals for you...
Any proof of your unsubstantiated libel?
--
My BLOG .. .. Internet News .. .. My Web Page
Ask yourself one question: 'Do I feel lucky?' Well, do ya punk?
patcat88

join:2002-04-05
Jamaica, NY

said by pabster See Profile :

Who needs advertising? Cash under the table is far more effective. If anyone believes Consumer Reports is truly OBJECTIVE and UNBIASED I have some terrific land deals for you...
Consumer Reports is willing, and has gone to court to support its negative reviews. It usually wins. Thats says something. No settling off the record for its negative reviews. So if a product is truly crap, CR will call it out without fear, not so with other media.
moonpuppy

join:2000-08-21
Glen Burnie, MD
·Verizon Online DSL

How many people were part of the survey?

Oh, and did you forget about the screw up Consumer Reports did with the child safety seat report that even the NTSB said was wrong.

»www.msnbc.msn.com/id/16691288/

Yeah, I trust Consumer Reports.
patcat88

join:2002-04-05
Jamaica, NY

said by pabster See Profile :

Not that AT&T has anything to brag about overall but if Verizon is really "tops" the U.S. Wireless industry is indeed in dismal shape.
Verizon brainwashes its users into thinking their service is excellent and the best and they must be wrong to think there can be anything wrong about it, and if there is something wrong, Verizon is the lesser of all the evils.

Zen6

@rr.com

Re: Corporate Reports?

I agree, my company phone is vz and my private is ATT. The phones are same model, only difference is the ATT phone does not drop calls nearly as often. The plans are the same except ATT is about 5$/mo cheaper.

NO to ESPN

@sbcglobal.net

Not the Best, But the Least Worst

Verizon Wireless is not the best but the least worst of the cell phone providers in the US. I know people who have corporate at&t cell phones that have bought Verizon cell phones so that they can communicate when they are out in the real world, in this case northern Kentucky.

I have lent my Verizon cell phones over the years to various people whose phones did not work in some specific area of the country. I will say the next "least worst" is T-Mobile based on my observations.

These are my opinions, you are entitled to yours.

en102
Canadian, eh?

join:2001-01-26
Valencia, CA
·RoadRunner Cable
·DSL EXTREME
·DSL EXTREME

Re: Not the Best, But the Least Worst

I agree with your viewpoint.
Also, there is typically very little difference (from what I've seen in the past) in overall ratings between the best and worst... meaning Verizon Wireless _really_ isn't that much better than Sprint. Similarly, Sprint isn't that much worse than Verizon Wireless
expert007

join:2006-01-10
Buffalo, NY

Verizon Anything????

I've had such bad experiences with Verizon, anything with their brand name makes me run the other way screaming like a frightened schoolgirl.
mAlfunkti0n

join:2003-12-16
Loveland, OH
·BroadVoice
·RoadRunner Cable

Re: Verizon Anything????

It just shows that people who enjoy Verizon also enjoy being nickle and dimed to death because every feature is disabled on their phones. Want to copy a photo you took from your phone? Hook it up to your PC and do the transfer ..? HA! But for a modest fee you can EMAIL it to yourself.

That's Verizon for you. Cripple the device so you can't do anything you SHOULD be able to do with it. EVERYTHING has a fee.
socrplyr

join:2008-03-25
Canton, OH

Re: Verizon Anything????

I had no problems using Bluetooth to transfer all the pics off my phone to my PC on my VX8300... Now I know they still have many thing locked down that I wish they didn't, but they have made progress in this area.

Boricua65
Oye, chico

join:2002-01-26
Puerto Rico

I have Verizon and a satisfied customer. I do agree that they nickle and dime you to death. I've learned to hack my phone and not have to deal with that mess. Transfer pictures between PC and phone...no problems; upload self-created ringtones...easy.
--
Yo te digo, el mundo esta jodido

swhitney2003
I can't drive 55.
Premium
join:2003-06-13
NH
clubs:

Re: Verizon Anything????

Same here. It has only gotten easier with the introduction of bluetooth on just about every phone. Also, some phones come with a generic mini/micro usb plug, which also makes it very easy to hack, no proprietary plugs!
bullet087

join:2006-05-17
Kingwood, TX
I could do wireless bluetooth photo transfer from my enV, Voyager, and Dare, to my computer, without hacks.

astiyosti1

@cherokeenc.tv

don't you know it this rep mad me switch plans when i bought the voyager same plan same price he said. Also he stated i had to in order my phone to work. I did but he did tell me he would credit me 6.99 for the recent purchases of ring tones so that i could re down load them. one month later i get a bill of 250.99 so i called and asked they replied with you have bee charged 1.99/mb usage fees.(Also note i put a block on the mobile web feature to prevent his in the past).The rep told me from now on when i even look at get it now vzn navigator or scroll for ring tones/ring-back tones its like downloading info now. Also even to pay my bill thought the mobile web will charge me around 6.00 surcharge lol.Hows that for phone service so i set my phone up to record song and or sounds then send it to me via text msg and set it as a ring tone so verizon can kiss my grit's
macgal12

join:2008-11-30
Fort Wayne, IN


edit:
December 2nd, @03:16PM

Sprint

I recently tried out service with Sprint. I paid over a hundred for the phone. I cancelled service and returned the phone. Its been more than a week since they got the phone back. Sprint still hasn't given me my money back for the phone. Sprint knows they have the phone back and that I didn't even use any minutes on the phone. Sprint is refusing to return my money until they send me out a "final" bill and then I have to call back in to request the money back. Once I request it they have to send the request to another department who reviews it for up to 48 hours before making a decision. If they grant it then they issue a check. Then it takes another few days before they mail it and then up to two weeks for me to get the check.

In all of this Sprint Customer Service stinks as my experience proves.
fitbryan

join:2005-07-26
Santa Monica, CA

Re: Sprint

great now if we could just get them to stop crippling phones...

Mr Fingers

@dslextreme.com
I just did the same thing with Sprint. They sent me a final bill of $0, called them back and within a week I had my refund check.
Quit bitching
pabster

join:2001-12-09
Waterloo, IA
·Mediacom

Perhaps this proves how technically inept the public is...

...If they think Verizon is really the best. LOL. As several others have pointed out, Verizon disables just about everything on their handsets. No bluetooth transfers. You get to pay for everything, nickel and dimed to death. Then again, the average Joe is apparently clueless and probably believes they (Verizon) disabled or neutered certain features for their benefit!

alanhdsl
Premium
join:1999-10-09
Phoenix, AZ

Re: Perhaps this proves how technically inept the public is...

I guess it depends on you want. Verizon does not have the coolest phones, and does tend to charge a lot of add-on fees.

On the other hand, you can reliably make phone calls.

Boricua65
Oye, chico

join:2002-01-26
Puerto Rico

Re: Perhaps this proves how technically inept the public is...

said by alanhdsl See Profile :

On the other hand, you can reliably make phone calls.
Word. I was in Mexico (Guadalajara and Puerto Vallarta) and made calls from my phone without a hiccup.
--
Yo te digo, el mundo esta jodido
patcat88

join:2002-04-05
Jamaica, NY

Re: Perhaps this proves how technically inept the public is...

said by Boricua65 See Profile :

said by alanhdsl See Profile :

On the other hand, you can reliably make phone calls.
Word. I was in Mexico (Guadalajara and Puerto Vallarta) and made calls from my phone without a hiccup.
Verizon doesn't have service there. You were roaming.

TK Junk Mail
Go ahead, make my day
Premium
join:2002-03-03
Margate City, NJ
clubs:
·Comcast

said by alanhdsl See Profile :

I guess it depends on you want. Verizon does not have the coolest phones, and does tend to charge a lot of add-on fees.

On the other hand, you can reliably make phone calls.

And that is the metric MOST of the customers care about. Can they connect anywhere they are? Will it stay connected while moving in a car? Voice quality, etc. Almost everything else is of much lower importance for the vast majority of users.
--
My BLOG .. .. Internet News .. .. My Web Page
Ask yourself one question: 'Do I feel lucky?' Well, do ya punk?

James Fisher

@sprintlink.net

Sprint Responds

I am in Sprint's communications group, and here are my thoughts. Yes, we are in last place, but our extensive efforts in 2008 to offer the best customer service have resulted in improvement in almost every market in the Consumer Reports survey, and all results were above the 60 threshold which indicates that respondents are "fairly well satisfied" with service and connectivity. That's not the best, but our improvements are paying off and third parties are regularly citing that. J.D. Power has indicated we have improved in much of the country, and Pali Research recently reported we went from last to first in their survey of customer service. Our internal measures show dramatic improvement in customer service, and it just takes time for that to be fully reflected in customer responses. But we are getting there. And as for the snarky remark about our being last to offer prorated ETFs so customers won't "flee," we were delayed only because the massive integration of computer systems following our merger prevented us from doing it sooner. Regarding the CR study, yes, we weren't at the top, but don't for a minute think we aren't working as hard as possible every day to get there.
macgal12

join:2008-11-30
Fort Wayne, IN


edit:
December 2nd, @04:19PM

Re: Sprint Responds

I just have three things to say to this.

1) I called Sprint days ago and although Sprint sent me a return label by email Sprint didn't have the tracking # in there systems.

2) Sprint CS has always treated me rudely and as an idiot.

3) Verizon CS has never given me any crap. PERIOD.

Edit: The thread starter said they made improvements in several markets. No matter what day I call I still get the item #2 treatment.

xxA4Hxx

@ivytech.edu

Re: Sprint Responds

I rather pay sprint 99.99 for simply everything then verizon almost 99 for 450 minutes and data and text. I think last I calculated it was that or 89.99 But that doesnt include gps which still additional fee.

-illusion

PS. I have had them all , this year tmobile jack up their rates for little service they provide. Att pricey like verizon. ATT getting little bad with customer service recently from my experince. Then you have verizon, locked down , high price for less. lol , I figure most of the time I can get sprint to do what I want. Just going to get the plan and everything I want so I never have to really call. Honestly most people dont really ever have to call their cell phone company til they want a new phone. Yes I know telesales department is the worst department because returning phones is a snail process.

James Fisher

@sprintlink.net
To Macgal12, if you are a Sprint customer and not satisfied, contact me directly at james.w.fisher@sprint.com

Packeteers
Premium
join:2005-06-18
Forest Hills, NY
Mr.Fisher - honestly - how much longer is Sprint going to use their doomed 2005 merger with Nextel as an excuse for being such screw ups? years? decades?
ISurfTooMuch

join:2007-04-23
Tuscaloosa, AL

AT&T and VZW

I guess what carrier you prefer is ultimately a personal choice. I've had both AT&T and VZW, and I like AT&T much better. Around here, their coverage is rock solid, probably because BellSouth did a good job building out the network in the '8s and '90s. VZW is also pretty good (I have them for my work phone), but their coverage isn't as robust as AT&T's and certainly not as good as they'd have you believe. I also like the fact that AT&T doesn't lock down their phones like VZW does. Granted, there are ways to hack them and get around those restrictions, but I shouldn't have to hack my phone just to transfer a file to it. I paid for the damn thing. It's mine, so I see no reason I must pay VZW to simply add a ringtone to it. And if I don't like AT&T's phone selection, I can go out andbuy an unlocked handset, pop my SIM in, and use it. No need to beg them for permission.

I'm not saying AT&T is perfect, but I think lots of people have drunk the VZW Kool-Aid that their network is somehow better than everyone else's. Truth be told, Southern LINC probably has the best network around here, but I don't need their PTT service, and I hate iDEN devices, so I find AT&T to be the best carrier for me right now.

sixmaier

@rr.com

Re: AT&T and VZW

I travel the U.S. from coast-to-coast throughout every week of the year and I too have both an AT&T and Verizon phone. The only reason I have two is because where I live on the Panhandle of Florida, Verizon service is pretty weak, especially along the I-10 path. I carry a Verizon phone because it's the best everywhere else. Their EVDO network is second to none and they truly don't drop calls. When I get on my plane Monday morning, my iPhone gets forwarded to my VZW Curve and it stays that way until I get back home. Now that VZW and Alltel are merging, I will finally be able to dump my AT&T phone.

TK Junk Mail
Go ahead, make my day
Premium
join:2002-03-03
Margate City, NJ
clubs:
·Comcast

If a CR online subscriber, link to ratings here...

... »www.consumerreports.org/cro/elec···ings.htm
scsiguru

join:2000-11-18
Parkersburg, WV

edit:
December 2nd, @09:48PM

Re: If a CR online subscriber, link to ratings here...

nc

sanfranson
Norm, The Enourmous Basset
Premium
join:2001-02-08
San Francisco, CA
·SONIC.NET
·AT&T Yahoo


edit:
December 2nd, @07:24PM

NO-O-O-O-O-O-O-O-O-O-O-O-O-O-O-O-O!!

This survey cannot possibly have included San Francisco. To preserve myself from hypertension, I am posting part of my observation of Verizon Wireless from another site rather than recomposing it:

". . . It is not enough that Verizon Wireless should forfeit all its assets in punishment for its criminal, meretricious publicity. It is not enough that the executives who conceived this monstrous nationwide fraud should be confined to McNeil Island Federal Penetentiary forever. All this should be done, but the inmates who were Verizon executives should, in addition, be tended by Screws who were former Verizon Wireless telephone customer service reps.

An example, by way of, "The Mikado":

- - - After dragging his tin cup back and forth on the bars for an hour to attract the attention of a Screw - - -

Former Verizon Executive: "Can I have another piece of baloney? This one is full of worms.

Screw: We are sorry that you are not satisfied with our product.

FVE: OK. But can I have another piece of baloney?

Screw: Nothing is more important to us than the satisfaction of our inmates.

FVE: Ok. Ok. But I still need a new slice of baloney.

Screw: Are you sure that there are worms in your baloney?

FVE: They look like worms. They are squirming all over it and eating it.

Screw: Let me connect you with a dietitian who can help you.

FVE: Look, I don't need a dietitian. All I need is another slice of baloney. . . . . . .

Screw leaves.

- - - - thirty minutes pass - -

Enter 2nd Screw:

Hello. I'm Sandy. How can I assist you today?"


After a suitable number of years have passed, the former Verizon executives should be offered death as an alternative.

I am nothing if not merciful.
--
Cordially,

SANFRANSON

antdude
A Ninja Ant
Premium,VIP
join:2001-03-25

Internet too?

Does this include wireless Internet service?
robo74

join:2003-10-23
Harvard, IL
·AT&T DSL Service

You cant please everyone!

As mentioned, its a personal choice.

My company was a long time Cingular/AT&T, but somehow, sprint got them to switch over. Either way, sucks for me because they both are terrible in my area. I usually have to step outside to get a clear call on either network.

However, T-Mobile has always been full service here.

I tried something different this year and went with Verizon as I get a decent discount thru my company.
The CS has been great, always made sure my questions were answered, etc.
Phones, yea...I can get the GPS without paying for. Nothing a $120 device from buy.com couldnt do (Garmin).

So for me, verizon seems to be doing well. Great signal at the house and only found a few bad spots on my commute to work.

But everyone is different.

jhacker

join:2001-12-11
Peoria, IL
·Comcast
·Vonage
·Insight Communicat..
·AT&T Midwest

Seven Year Verizon Customer

I have been a Verizon customer for seven years, after having a very bad experience with US Cellular. In our area Verizon has the best coverage, followed by US Cellular. Companies like AT&T, T-mobile, Sprint/Nextel are far behind in this area based on what I've heard from my friends. And when we go on trips, Verizon coverage has always been flawless for our family.

I did have an incident five years ago with Verizon billing which almost caused me to cancel, but that was resolved to our satisfaction. Other than that, I've always had good experiences with their customer service.

I have to admit though that there are only two reasons I have stuck with Verizon this long. First, I get a discount on my account through my employer. This discount really only negates all the taxes and un-fees that Verizon (and probably every other company) throws on the bill. Also, most of my friends and relatives are on Verizon as well. That pretty much takes the worry out of using up all of the anytime minutes on our account.

I understand what others are saying about disabling phone features and tacking on extra charges for every feature. I don't like how Verizon disables features on its phones. But, I have figured out how to add ringtones to our phones without paying for them.
itguy05

join:2005-06-17
Camp Hill, PA

Notaround here - Verizon is the NOTwork

Not around here. Half the time I can hardly understand the users on Verizon with muffled connections, garbled calls and just poor performance.

They are most definitely the NOTwork. Around here AT&T is the best - some dropped calls (not with the new iPhone Firmware) but the reliability is EXCELLENT.

Verizon has a decent network but an AWESOME marketing machine.

Been With AT&Tingular since 2004 and no issues and have traveled the country and had great service. Ironically it was issues with Verizon's reliability that brought me to AT&Tingular.
Forums » Verizon Tops Consumer Reports Wireless Satisfaction Ratings


Friday, 09-Jan 04:05:50 Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Hosting by www.nac.net - DSL,Hosting & Co-lo | feedback | contact
over 9 years online! © 1999-2009 dslreports.com.