site Search:


 
   
story category
A UN Managed Internet?
ICANN says no need, offers new plan
by Karl Bode Monday 22-Nov-2004 tags: world
There's been an increasing amount of anti-American sentiment thrown in the direction of ICANN, with plenty of talk about how the UN or another global office should take over their management of the internet. Partially in response to those criticisms, ICANN has released a Strategic Plan (pdf) that outlines their intentions for the next three years. As the Register and the International Herald Tribune note, the plan is a sales pitch to those the world over that would like to see its authority yanked.

view: topics flat text 
Post a:

technick
Premium
join:2000-12-16
Wheat Ridge, CO
kudos:1

1 edit

Crap!

Didn't we start he internet? I believe we did, and I also believe that US owned companies control the majority of the internet. So I honestly do not believe that the control should go to the UN ever.

As far as the pass ICANN, there's alot that can be improved. I think they can be a lil more harsh on violations, and should of canceled verisigns contract to be a root server as soon as sitefinder was launched.

It will only come down to one thing though, time. We will see who has the better package, but I do not wish to see the US lose control of the internet.

Improfane

join:2003-12-05
kudos:1

1 edit

Re: Crap!

technick,
quote:
Didn't we start he internet? I believe we did, and I also believe that US owned companies control the majority of the internet. So I honestly do believe that the control should go to the UN ever.

You can have the internet, we'll have everything listed on this page : -
»inventors.about.com/library/inve···tors.htm

You don't want to? Then Shut up.

If you have anything decent or constructive to say, then say it - Otherwise do not.

technick
Premium
join:2000-12-16
Wheat Ridge, CO
kudos:1

Re: Crap!

Such a pointless post, why don't we compare apples to grapes, or chickens to goat. I notice the internet is not on that list, though I think some of the things ont he list are used more so then the internet, such as the Rubber Band. But again, has my country tried to tell your country how to run the rubberband factories?
--
"Our greatest glory consists not in never falling, but in rising everytime we fall." - Confucius - - - - - - - - - - - Streamfire.net- - AIM - CoNFuCiUsNiCk

DaDogs
Semper Vigilantis
Premium
join:2004-02-28
Deltaville, VA
said by Improfane:

technick,
quote:
Didn't we start he internet? I believe we did, and I also believe that US owned companies control the majority of the internet. So I honestly do not believe that the control should go to the UN ever.

You can have the internet, we'll have everything listed on this page : -
»inventors.about.com/library/inve···tors.htm

You don't want to? Then Shut up.

If you have anything decent or constructive to say, then say it - Otherwise do not.
Do try to remain civil, next thing you know you are going to be calling us "ugly Americans."
--
I'd rather chew sand than watch sixty seconds of NBC.

calvoiper

join:2003-03-31
Belvedere Tiburon, CA

Re: Crap!

I dunno that it's so much that the US wants to control it.

I just think that we don't want the UN and its corruption using it as a cash cow.

calvoiper
--
VoIP--the death knell of remaining voice monopolies!

Improfane

join:2003-12-05
kudos:1

1 edit
I didn't say that, I was merely pointing out that the fact that he wants the UN to control the Internet.

I said that if UN wants to control the internet then he should think about other things such as what you said, elastic bands or toilet paper for example.
You cant have it always your way or always be boss.
That spoken, I have nothing against America just the fact that you want the internet to be controlled by the UN.
I am sure things have been originally made in Britain that have become a regularity to your life, We are going to control it now and you can have no say

Goober
Premium
join:2000-12-17
Naperville, IL
kudos:5
Reviews:
·Dish Network

Re: Crap!

said by Improfane:

I didn't say that, I was merely pointing out that the fact that he wants the UN to control the Internet.

I said that if UN wants to control the internet then he should think about other things such as what you said, elastic bands or toilet paper for example.
You cant have it always your way or always be boss.
That spoken, I have nothing against America just the fact that you want the internet to be controlled by the UN.
I am sure things have been originally made in Britain that have become a regularity to your life, We are going to control it now and you can have no say
Toilet paper was actually invented by an American. Look closer at the list and click on the inventor name. You'll see the correction/clarification and further information.

Improfane

join:2003-12-05
kudos:1

Re: Crap!

My mistake, I am sure there are other better examples.
Just understand my point of you claiming that 'the UN should control the Internet everywhere'
This is like saying it is OK for an original British invention company claiming all the similar companies in the US...

Goober
Premium
join:2000-12-17
Naperville, IL
kudos:5
Reviews:
·Dish Network

1 edit

Re: Crap!

said by Improfane:


My mistake, I am sure there are other better examples.
Just understand my point of you claiming that 'the UN should control the Internet everywhere'
This is like saying it is OK for an original British invention company claiming all the similar companies in the US...
I think you mean to say, "that the *US* should control . . . "

I agree that the internet, tcp/ip, etc. is no longer a US invention (if it ever was an invention, per se. It was however developed by the US). I don't think the UN should control it though. I think a non-UN controlled consortium of the biggest internet using countries should be created. Each should have only a single vote--regardless of how many people or how much money that country spends. Something along those lines. It would somehow need to be depoliticised and not accept any type of special interest money.

Not an easy task.

Random Scots Dude

@151.143.x.x
Why don't you separate out the Scottish inventors from that list and see what remains?

NOVA_Guy
ObamaCare Kills Americans
Premium
join:2002-03-05
I don't see the point of your post. It seems like just about everything the UN gets their hands on these days they just muck up.

Examples:
- Oil For Food Program
- Iraqi Weapons Inspections

Or even worse, they try to ram their ultra-liberal-left-wing viewpoint down the world's throat.

Examples:
- World Court
- World Handgun Control Program

The UN pretty much stands for Useless Nations as far as I'm concerned. It only creates a stage for wanna-be superpower nations to air their "grievances" against the United States, no matter how stupid, unjust, or ill-conceived they may be.

I would sooner see the Internet collapse than have the UN gain control over it.
--
I'm proud to have supported the better man in this election, and look forward to supporting him for another four years in his second term.
misukov

join:2004-11-23
10000

Re: Crap! - Yea , sure , Gore inented it.



We, 80% of rhe globe, dont trust tou handling anything-
you also made the furst Nuke and burned two cities in the test.

now Haliburton got you in a mess in Irak, and some Gringo message is geting a copy of this message.
Let the UN handle communication

pnh102
Reptiles Are Cuddly And Pretty
Premium
join:2002-05-02
Mount Airy, MD

Screw both of t hem

We don't need ICANN or the UN "managing" the Internet in any way, shape or form. ICANN couldn't give a rat's @$$ about domain transfer security and has mismanaged many other things (e.g., not yanking NSI's domain management contracts for their SiteFinder BS). The UN is just well, the UN.
--
Hey Fast Eddie... you're next!

GlenQuagmire
Giggidy Giggidy Giggidy Goo
Premium
join:2004-02-16
Grand Rapids, MI

1 edit

Build your own

If the UN has a problem with the Internet then BUILD YOUR OWN. I can't stand these UN bitches telling us what to do with our country. We created it so we get to control is. Why don't you go do something useful and take care of North Korea.

pnh102
Reptiles Are Cuddly And Pretty
Premium
join:2002-05-02
Mount Airy, MD

Re: Build you own

said by GlenQuagmire:

Why don't you go do something useful and take care of North Korea.
Or stop the genocide in Darfur, Sudan.
--
Hey Fast Eddie... you're next!
Freezone

join:2000-09-29
Southfield, MI

Re: Build you own

said by pnh102:

said by GlenQuagmire:

Why don't you go do something useful and take care of North Korea.
Or stop the genocide in Darfur, Sudan.
Hello thereis no money in that. Now oil for food scams that was good till Bush went and messed that up for them. Now they need the internet and other things to make up for all that money (sickning amounts) that the UN members were stealing.

technick
Premium
join:2000-12-16
Wheat Ridge, CO
kudos:1
Agreed... I honestly think the UN is a bunch of pansy's

sbhusted

join:2000-05-14
Bethlehem, PA
Reviews:
·PenTeleData
I can't belive you would say such a thing about the UN!. I mean, look at the honorable and dignified way they handled the Iraqi Oil for Food Program and the follow up investigation!!


--
Scott B. Hustedhttp://www.Husted.cc
xrobertcmx
Premium
join:2001-06-18
Sterling, VA

Re: Build you own

Almost as gracefully as the administration handled the Sept 11th commission investigation.
--
4 More years and we won't have a country.
Freezone

join:2000-09-29
Southfield, MI
said by GlenQuagmire:

If the UN has a problem with the Internet then BUILD YOUR OWN. I can't stand these UN bitches telling us what to do with our country. We created it so we get to control is. Why don't you go do something useful and take care of North Korea.
Come on that is not fair. how can they do that with out AL GORE

Nanoprobe
Looking for cures in memory of Mom
Premium
join:2003-05-11
Crab Nebula
kudos:2

Re: Build you own

Tell the UN they can have the internet if they take Al Gore too.
--
Never look back.Something might be gaining on you.
navalpatel

join:2003-07-28
Richardson, TX

Bargain

I saw we use the internet as a bargaining tool. If there is any country that we don't get along with, then we give them a choice - either do what we say or we will yank the internet. I am sure most countries around the world would be much more willing to negotiate if we offered them that.

If all else fails - use the nukes. :-P

technick
Premium
join:2000-12-16
Wheat Ridge, CO
kudos:1

Re: Bargain

Doing that will cause private networks to spring up, and someone will find a way around it by NAT'ing one ip address to a million people pretty much. The internet is so big I do not think that is possible really. Nice thought though =). Can we kick Korea and China off first?
--
"Our greatest glory consists not in never falling, but in rising everytime we fall." - Confucius - - - - - - - - - - - Streamfire.net- - AIM - CoNFuCiUsNiCk

aztecnology
O Rly?
Premium
join:2003-02-12
Murrieta, CA

Re: Bargain

said by technick:

Doing that will cause private networks to spring up, and someone will find a way around it by NAT'ing one ip address to a million people pretty much. The internet is so big I do not think that is possible really. Nice thought though =). Can we kick Korea and China off first?
We could still see a million different MAC's coming from a single ip... "no soup for you" "deny all"...
--
.:|:.Tell a man there are 300 billion stars in the universe and he'll believe you. Tell him a bench has wet paint on it and he'll have to touch it to be sure. .:|:.
dave
Premium,MVM
join:2000-05-04
not in ohio
kudos:8

Re: Bargain

said by aztecnology:

We could still see a million different MAC's coming from a single ip...
Now there's a man who has a sure grasp of the interrelationship between layers 2 and 3.

calvoiper

join:2003-03-31
Belvedere Tiburon, CA
said by technick:

...Can we kick Korea and China off first?
Nah. Letting the have the Internet is more harmful to their oppressive ways than yanking it.

calvoiper
--
VoIP--the death knell of remaining voice monopolies!
dave
Premium,MVM
join:2000-05-04
not in ohio
kudos:8
said by navalpatel:

I saw we use the internet as a bargaining tool. If there is any country that we don't get along with, then we give them a choice - either do what we say or we will yank the internet.
Now there's a man who has a sure grasp of 'dynamic adaptive routing'.

2134513a

@cpe.net.cable.rogers

Re: Bargain


MadDog3057
Ex Astris, Scientia
Premium
join:2002-02-26
Miami, FL

Let's start working.....

We can start working on Internet3. We'll deploy fiber all over the place and it'll be an even better place than Internet2.
--
"The only thing that’s worse than being blind is having sight but no vision."

hailinfantry
Bizarro Quinn
Premium
join:2004-01-18
Brooklyn, NY

Re: Let's start working.....

said by MadDog3057:

We can start working on Internet3. We'll deploy fiber all over the place and it'll be an even better place than Internet2.
What the hell are you talking about? This isn't "internet2." Internet2 is a private edu and research network. It doesn't mean this is the 2nd internet
--
Leon: No, I forget sometimes.. you see, my old manager at the Orange Julius is named Doug, and, uh.. anyway, I think I should tell you, the.. uh.. computer you're looking at is for gays.Customer: What?!

Some Random Dude

@151.143.x.x

Re: Let's start working.....

He means that seeing as how the MPAA now wants to play in the Internet2 group, progress and freedom will suffer and we need to start working proactively on a replacement...Internet3.

MadDog3057
Ex Astris, Scientia
Premium
join:2002-02-26
Miami, FL

Re: Let's start working.....

said by Some Random Dude:

He means that seeing as how the MPAA now wants to play in the Internet2 group, progress and freedom will suffer and we need to start working proactively on a replacement...Internet3.
Finally someone that understands me!
--
"The only thing that’s worse than being blind is having sight but no vision."

reub2000
Premium
join:2001-12-28
Evanston, IL

dns != internet

I'm reading all this talk about control of the internet. Remember that DNS != the internet. Sure the internet is dependent on dns and the root servers run by icann. If the UN wants to, they can start running their dns root servers with their own tld.

calvoiper

join:2003-03-31
Belvedere Tiburon, CA

Re: dns != internet

Yeah--and then they'll learn who really wants to line Kofi Anan's pockets--NOBODY!

calvoiper
--
VoIP--the death knell of remaining voice monopolies!

Sr Tech
Premium
join:2003-01-19
New Fairfield, CT

UN cannot even manage them selves

UN cannot even manage them selves and they want to control the internet. Seeing after how well they ran the UN for Food project and putting that in the dumper.
King75
King Of All And Nothing
Premium
join:2004-07-31
Stevensville, MD

Let them

We basically run the UN we are the greatest source of funds, man power, and troops to the UN. They are in our back pocket they can have it. If they ever implemented this they would probably get most of the people from ICANN to run it anyways.

Kompressor
Premium
join:2002-02-12
Huntington Beach, CA

Internet Invasion

First people try to take over the world, now they try to take over the Internet.

parasonic
I Am Not A Bot

join:2002-03-29
Atlanta, GA

Re: Internet Invasion

Kompressor: We must DESTROY UN

bit_junkie

join:2004-05-04
Maricopa, AZ

LOL the UN

giving control of the internet to the UN would be like locking a kid in a candystore all by him/herself and telling them not to touch any of it.
the UN cant even control themselves.

Janie6

@dsl.gulftelephone.ne

un controlling the internet...

I have to agree with reub2000....the UN wants to control the Internet...fine....BUILD YOUR OWN....stay the hell off ours....

reub2000
Premium
join:2001-12-28
Evanston, IL

Re: un controlling the internet...

That's not what I said. AFAIK, all the UN controls is the DNS system. It's a service that runs over the internet, so they don't control the internet.

They are free to run their own DNS system. Some people already do so.

Transmaster
Don't Blame Me I Voted For Bill and Opus

join:2001-06-20
Cheyenne, WY
Reviews:
·CenturyLink

2 edits

UN

If you stop and think about it the UN is well named;

UN know in trouble spots
UN true
UN lawful
UN ......fill in the blanks

It is unfortunate but the UN is going the way of the League of Nations. It is a corrupt, debating society of 1st world hating third world dictatorships with countries like France who because of their diminishing role on the world stage hate the United States. It is good we have a President who properly sees the UN for what it is. Bush is willing to work with the UN but will not be dictated to by it.
--
Real Men use Vacuum tubes, 25 pound filament transformers, and plate voltages no less then 2400 volts...BPL I'm coming to get you

Saturday, 18-May 15:23:24 Terms of Use & Privacy | feedback | contact | Hosting by nac.net - DSL,Hosting & Co-lo
over 13.5 years online © 1999-2013 dslreports.com.