Search:  

 
 
   News
newer
321 Studios plays hard to get
DVD CopyX to ship minus infringing code
(old news - 01:22PM Monday Feb 23 2004)
tags: legal
According to the WSJ online, 321 Studios is leaping its recent court defeat by planning to continue to ship DVD CopyX minus the DMCA infringing decryption code. As Linux users of open source DVD burning software are aware, it is trivial to google for and download the necessary DMCA infringing code block from multiple offshore web servers. It is possible that 321 Studios will be able to build a connector to this software, thus both obeying the DMCA, and not cutting into its profit margins. The 321 Studios press release is here.

Related:
  1. Comcast Eager To See Kevin Martin Take A Hike
  2. NebuAD, Several ISPs Sued Over Behavioral Ads
  3. Harvard Law Professor Sues RIAA
  4. Martin, Comcast, Continue Lover's Feud
  5. AT&T Tells Us Customer Service Critique Unfair
  6. AT&T, Verizon: Privacy Advocates Extraordinaire
  7. Canadian Regulators Strangling Independent ISPs
  8. UK May Still Adopt '3 Strikes' Anti-Piracy Law
Forums » 321 Studios plays hard to get
view: topics flat text 
Post a:
djrobsd

join:2002-01-24
San Diego, CA

Why pay for this crap anyway

Go to google, search for dvd decryptor. Download, install.

Go to google, search for dvd shrink. Download, install.

Install Nero if you haven't already to burn the dvd.

Open the decryptor.

Rip DVD to computer

If DVD is > then 4.7GB, open DVD shrink and shrink it down to 4.7GB or split into 2 dvd's.

Burn with Nero and enjoy.

Whole process for me takes less then 45 minutes with a 4x dvd burner.

Spazmoto
Dark Flow

join:2003-08-22
Hyperspace

Re: Why pay for this crap anyway

Seconded.

BIGMIKE
"I do not know with what weapons World W
Premium
join:2002-06-07
Westminster, CA

edit:
February 23rd, @01:39PM

Re: Why pay for this crap anyway

Why pay for ENE program

third

mig
Premium,MVM
join:2000-10-26
Anytown, USA
clubs:

I don't know why people want to pay for a piece of software to do what freeware software will do. Why would anyone want to use software that they pay for that puts a watermark on their backed up dvd? That's just ridiculous.

As said above, Use DVD Decrypter, DVDShrink and your favorite burning software!

jdeare1
Slowride
Premium
join:2002-07-02
Wheaton, IL

Re: Why pay for this crap anyway

Here's why...

You could buy it CompUSA, Best Buy, etc. Therefore, it has to be legal, right?

mig
Premium,MVM
join:2000-10-26
Anytown, USA
clubs:

Re: Why pay for this crap anyway

said by jdeare1 See Profile:
Here's why...

You could buy it CompUSA, Best Buy, etc. Therefore, it has to be legal, right?

As of today it's still legal......still doesn't change the fact that with other software out there, that paying for this piece of software is ridiculous. The arguement that many people have the AOL mentality and want to just click a button is alright by me. If they want to spend their money on it that's OK by me too.

BlKrAiN

join:2002-04-08
Bensalem, PA

I second the second. I use dvd decrypter,dvd shrink, and nero and it's by far the best way to go to make backups of your dvd collection. Had tried dvd x copy platinum and made 4 coasters. You be the judge!

Mick1

join:2001-04-22
San Jose, CA

said by djrobsd See Profile:
Go to google, search for dvd decryptor. Download, install.
Go to google, search for dvd shrink. Download, install.

i have both dvdxcopy and dvdshrink. dvdshrink works very well however, the vob files that it produces sometimes would cause the dvd authorizing software to break up the mpeg-2 encoding into multiple files. the ones from dvdxcopy does not have this problem.

when there are several mpeg-2 files instead of one, you would see a slight pause at the point when they connect. with one mpeg-2 file, there is no pause to speak of.

so, dvdshrink works very well but if you're getting multiple mpeg-2 files when authorizing the dvd, use dvdxcopy.

Voyager2K2

join:2001-10-04
Wayne, PA
·Verizon FIOS

Re: Why pay for this crap anyway

said by Mick1 See Profile:
said by djrobsd See Profile:
Go to google, search for dvd decryptor. Download, install.
Go to google, search for dvd shrink. Download, install.

i have both dvdxcopy and dvdshrink. dvdshrink works very well however, the vob files that it produces sometimes would cause the dvd authorizing software to break up the mpeg-2 encoding into multiple files. the ones from dvdxcopy does not have this problem.

when there are several mpeg-2 files instead of one, you would see a slight pause at the point when they connect. with one mpeg-2 file, there is no pause to speak of.

so, dvdshrink works very well but if you're getting multiple mpeg-2 files when authorizing the dvd, use dvdxcopy.

You have absolutely no idea what you are talking about sir.

Mick1

join:2001-04-22
San Jose, CA


edit:
February 23rd, @07:20PM

Re: Why pay for this crap anyway

said by Voyager2K2 See Profile:
You have absolutely no idea what you are talking about sir.

on the contrary, i don't think you understand what i'm talking about. i'm not talking about straight copying from the source dvd. i'm talking about editing the content of the vob files from the dvd, where you would have to cut out a significant number of frames from the vob files. for instance, if you want to make a dvd of all the chase scenes from all the James Bond movies, you would have to cut out the other scenes to do this and then connect all the chase scenes together.

I guess not too many people would do this but for those who would do it, dvdxcopy works better than dvdshrink because its vob files do not break into multiple mpeg-2 files when you do the encoding.

the point of my post is simply dvdxcopy can do something that dvdshrink cannot do.

Voyager2K2

join:2001-10-04
Wayne, PA
·Verizon FIOS

Re: Why pay for this crap anyway

I still contend you have a great deal of reading at dvdrhelp.com and doom9.net until you understand the terms transcoding and re-encoding particularly with CCE and motion prediction before you are able to comment on copying a DVD-9 to a DVD-5.
DVDShrink does not "break VOB files, it transcodes them.
DVDxCopy like DVDFab determines "break points" that allows you to split a DVD-9 (or dual layer DVD) into 2 writable DVD-5's but does so without altering VOB's

Sorry.

Spazmoto
Dark Flow

join:2003-08-22
Hyperspace

Re: Why pay for this crap anyway

Uh, DVD players and ROMs read one layer then then switch to the second layer halfway through don't they?
--
"...They don't know...They can't see...Are you one of them?..."

Voyager2K2

join:2001-10-04
Wayne, PA
·Verizon FIOS

Re: Why pay for this crap anyway

said by Spazmoto See Profile:
Uh, DVD players and ROMs read one layer then then switch to the second layer halfway through don't they?

WRITABLE discs
dual-layer WRITABLES aren't due out until Q2 '04

2.5GB VOB Mick? Please do your homewark

You guys are scary BTW.

And yes whoever questioned it DVD writables can and are sometimes called just + or - when generically referring to a particular format's properties.

PLEASE folks go to dvdrhelp and or doom9 and read up.
There is so much to learn and you really can't bluff or guess your way through it.

It's a really interesting hobby for some of us.
You will also learn why DVDxCOPY without Derrow's fix was a steamy pile of poop and DVDFab can split a DVD-9 doing just as good a job as DVDxCOPY as well learning how to do a far better job compressing a DVD-9 to a DVD-5 than ANY commercial program is capable of if you want to take the time to learn.

I promise.

Mick1

join:2001-04-22
San Jose, CA


edit:
February 23rd, @09:37PM

Re: Why pay for this crap anyway

said by Voyager2K2 See Profile:

2.5GB VOB Mick? Please do your homewark

No. not a 2.5 gb vob file but a 2.5 gb mpeg-2 file. tmpgenc dvd author would combine all the vob files into one giant mpeg-2 file for the user to edit.

from the post above:
------------------
for example => 1:30 min dvd clip
generate mpeg-2 file from tmpgenc dvd author:
------------------

if you have used tmpgenc dvd author, you would understand precisely what i'm talking about. that is how that program works.

and i've been trying to tell you with the vob files from dvdshrink i would get two mpeg-2 files: one 1.5 gb mpeg-2 file and another one 1.0 gb mpeg-2 file. With the vob files from dvdxcopy, i would get only one 2.5 gb mpeg-2 file.

I've tried a number of times now with different dvds and always come up with the same result. there is something different in the way dvdxcopy and dvdshrink code the vob files.

If you want, i can post a screen shot for you to see.

Spazmoto
Dark Flow

join:2003-08-22
Hyperspace
·Verizon west (ex G..

said by Voyager2K2 See Profile:
said by Spazmoto See Profile:
Uh, DVD players and ROMs read one layer then then switch to the second layer halfway through don't they?

WRITABLE discs
dual-layer WRITABLES aren't due out until Q2 '04


Was that even remotely my question? No....
I was refering to the way dual-layer discs are read. Like not all at once, but one layer, then the next.
--
"...They don't know...They can't see...Are you one of them?..."

Mick1

join:2001-04-22
San Jose, CA


edit:
February 23rd, @08:32PM

well, voyager2k2, i'm not here to bash dvdshrink or to promote dvdxcopy. I'm only telling you guys my experience.

i use tmpgenc dvd authorize software to edit the vob files and first the vob files must be converted to mpeg-2. The vob files that i got from dvdshrink of the long scene (more than one hour) would break into multiple mpeg-2 files. the vob files of the same scene that i got from dvdxcopy would not break into multiple files when i convert it with the tmpgenc dvd authorize software.

for example => 1:30 min dvd clip
generate mpeg-2 file from tmpgenc dvd author:

vob files from dvd shrink to mpeg-2 = one 1.5 gb + one 1.0 gb files.
vob files from dvdxcopy to mpeg-2 = one 2.5 gb file.

this is all i'm saying.

now if you can tell me how to get one 2.5 gb file using tmpgenc dvd author and the vob files from dvdshrink, i would most appreciate it because dvdshrink is way much faster than dvdxcopy. I have tried doing that many times but i was never successful.

Sarick
It's Only Logical
Premium
join:2003-06-03
USA
·FrontierNet Intern..

THANK YOU! This free program will go nicely into my Archives.
Might never use it but. Useful to have in a Software CD. of Software DVD.

Security
OS patch's
Security Software
Security Patch's
Favorites
Security Links
Online Anti-Virus Scanner Links
Microsoft Links
Software Links
News Links
Software Apps
Nero
FireBird
Trillion
Music
(Midi's)
Digital Images
(desktops)

MP3's are Huge they go to another CD. Worthless since I have all the CD's.
--
Sarick's Dungeon Clipart Page
Trouble spelling? www.iespell.com

2kmaro
Think
Premium,ExMod 1 BC
join:2000-07-11
ColossalCave
clubs:

said by djrobsd See Profile:
Go to google, search for dvd decryptor. Download, install.

Go to google, search for dvd shrink. Download, install.

Install Nero if you haven't already to burn the dvd.

Open the decryptor.

Rip DVD to computer

If DVD is > then 4.7GB, open DVD shrink and shrink it down to 4.7GB or split into 2 dvd's.

Burn with Nero and enjoy.

Whole process for me takes less then 45 minutes with a 4x dvd burner.

And for those that need more guidance than that, check this out: »Software Applications FAQ »What is a good, inexpensive and easy way for me to backup my DVD collection?

As some people have noted, DVD Shrink does do both the ripping and the burning (with Nero installed on the system already) - but I still like the results that using the 3 independent programs gives.

I think that 321 Studios is going to end up taking a beating if they continue to try to distribute the X Copy series and then tell people they have to use another program to perform the 1st stage of the process. People are buying those packages to get results with a one-button push. They are not going to be pleased with it. That's besides the point that there are excellent FREE solutions to the problem that do not take an ubergeek to work with.
--
Good judgment comes from experience, and experience comes from bad judgment. Barry LePatner

bltsob
Evil By Desire
Premium
join:2002-09-03
Richeyville, PA
·Atlantic Broadband


edit:
February 23rd, @01:37PM

2 vs 1

Why not just use dvd shrink to rip the dvd to.. i do, works fine for me... no need for a extra program..

plus with the latest version of dvd shrink, it will rip, then automaticly burn right to a blank dvd useing a nero plugin..
--
The Darkness is to Hard to overcome..

wozster
Premium
join:2000-10-21
Lenexa, KS

Re: 2 vs 1

Ditto
Shrink is all you really need (if you already have the NERO engine)
--
Protect online free speech

shewitts

join:2001-04-22
Clearfield, UT

Re: 2 vs 1

Shrink works without nero plugin, I just checked for a plugin and I dont have any but it works great for me.:D
Duke311

join:2001-09-16
Dayton, OH

I will say that DVD x copy is easy. For the millions of people that can barely turn on their computer by themselves, dvd x copy allows them to make a backup. It truely is idiot proof. For the rest of us there are freeware programs

skyjock41
Shag Diesel
Premium
join:2001-12-11
Ledyard, CT
clubs:
·Comcast

Re: 2 vs 1

said by Duke311 See Profile:
I will say that DVD x copy is easy. For the millions of people that can barely turn on their computer by themselves, dvd x copy allows them to make a backup. It truely is idiot proof. For the rest of us there are freeware programs

Agreed. People like AOL type programs. Thats why DVD X Copy is so popular.
--
My CPU: P4 2.6c, 2x 512MB PC3200 Crucial, Abit IS7-E Motherboard, 120GIG HD, 30GIG HD, SONY 52X CDRW, SONY DRU510A DVD+/-, Thermaltake Xaser III V1000A Super Tower , 480W Thermaltake SilentSilver Power Supply, 19inch CRT, and ATI Radeon 9800Pro 128MB.

bltsob
Evil By Desire
Premium
join:2002-09-03
Richeyville, PA
·Atlantic Broadband

Re: 2 vs 1

said by skyjock41 See Profile:

Agreed. People like AOL type programs. Thats why DVD X Copy is so popular.

Dvd x copy xpress IS idiot proof... Instrustions. Put dvd in drive, click GO, put dvd in other drive...DONE

Damn aol newbies!!
--
The Darkness is to Hard to overcome..

raydog1
Feel Secure
Premium
join:2003-07-10
La Vergne, TN

Re: 2 vs 1

said by bltsob See Profile:
said by skyjock41 See Profile:

Agreed. People like AOL type programs. Thats why DVD X Copy is so popular.

Dvd x copy xpress IS idiot proof... Instrustions. Put dvd in drive, click GO, put dvd in other drive...DONE


EXACTLY!

I've got too many other apps to "learn" for home, work, and school to make copying a freakin' movie my "hobby."

When I first got my Sony DRU-500AX, the only program I ever heard of that would copy DVDs was DVD X Copy. I've never had a single coaster. I heard about the Shrink/Decrypter combo a month ago and gave it a shot. I got a visually beautiful copy. . . with sound coming out of only one speaker!

I want the same ease and reliabilty that Nero gives me with CDs. Pop the movie in, let it do its thing, kthnxgby.

aurgathor

join:2002-12-01
Lynnwood, WA
·Verizon west (ex G..

said by skyjock41 See Profile:
said by Duke311 See Profile:
I will say that DVD x copy is easy. For the millions of people that can barely turn on their computer by themselves, dvd x copy allows them to make a backup. It truely is idiot proof. For the rest of us there are freeware programs

Agreed. People like AOL type programs. Thats why DVD X Copy is so popular.

Not sure why DVD X Copy is "so popular" (is it?!?) and I'd kinda question the idiotproof portion, too -- I tried it once to copy a DVD, and it took a little over 2 days (!!) to copy one friggin DVD. (dual PIII w/768 meg memory). The DVD had 3 old Frankenstein movies worth about 8.5 Gig, so it had to compress it almost 50%, though. BTW, I have a screenshot at home showing progress around halftime...

Anyhow, that was the first and last time I used DVD X Copy; Decrypter and shrink are just so much faster and versatile, even if the content requires some compression.
lefty1

join:2002-10-25
Clay, NY

Does DVD Shrink work with the DVD+ format? I have 2 homemeade DVD's; both +, neither encrypted, and whenever I try to copy them using DVD Shrink, it gives me an error message and crashes. I've tried it on both DVD's numerous times over a period of months with the exact same results every time.

Phil Hall

Rhobite
Premium
join:2002-02-24
Cambridge, MA
clubs:

Re: DVD Shrink

said by lefty1 See Profile:
I have 2 homemeade DVD's; both +, neither encrypted, and whenever I try to copy them using DVD Shrink, it gives me an error message and crashes.
There's no such thing as DVD+. Do you mean DVD+R? That's just a physical format-- DVD+R and DVD-R have no effect on the actual data.

Now if these discs are homemade you don't need to use a transcoder like DVD shrink. They're under the 4.7GB barrier so you can just go ahead and make an exact copy with Nero or your favorite burning software. No need to use DVD Shrink.

If I had to guess I'd say they had authoring errors, which may be tolerated by a hardware DVD player but may cause DVD Shrink to choke.
--
Jimmysquid.com - I take pictures.

Voyager2K2

join:2001-10-04
Wayne, PA
·Verizon FIOS

said by bltsob See Profile:
Why not just use dvd shrink to rip the dvd to.. i do, works fine for me... no need for a extra program..

plus with the latest version of dvd shrink, it will rip, then automaticly burn right to a blank dvd useing a nero plugin..

How timely!
New version of DVD Shrink released 2/23/04
»www.dvdshrink.org/where.html

skyjock41
Shag Diesel
Premium
join:2001-12-11
Ledyard, CT
clubs:
·Comcast


moderated:
February 29th, @01:57AM

I use DVD X Copy xpress cause i have it and i dont want 2 dvds for one movie. What does that mean? Yes it is compressed and quality isnt as good as a dvd. But if you said a dvd is 10 out of 10 then my compressed movie would be 9 of 10.....so its no big deal.

--
My CPU: P4 2.6c, 2x 512MB PC3200 Crucial, Abit IS7-E Motherboard, 120GIG HD, 30GIG HD, SONY 52X CDRW, SONY DRU510A DVD+/-, Thermaltake Xaser III V1000A Super Tower , 480W Thermaltake SilentSilver Power Supply, 19inch CRT, and ATI Radeon 9800Pro 128MB.

Mactron
el Camino Real
Premium
join:2001-12-16
CM94sv


edit:
February 23rd, @08:16PM

Customers are now the infringer's?

This is a brilliant business plan, make the customer the infringer. Send them out Googling for the very code they got sued for!?? Hey, it's not are fault! Go sue the customers! I love it when a (business) plan comes together.:p

Edit add: an update from an interview with...

Russell Frackman, a lawyer for the movie studios that brought the lawsuit, questioned whether 321's response was consistent with the spirit of Illston's order.

"You can't sell the product with a wink and a nod and then tell your users, 'What you need to do is get the ripper (descrambling) component ... from another source,'" said Frackman said. "The law generally does not permit one to do indirectly what they can't do directly."

GNXPower
Got Boost?
Premium
join:2003-12-18
Huntington Beach, CA

Wish the Ed would post story links...

...that don't require registration.

See 10 replies to this post
AlBester

join:2003-10-05
Bluffton, IN

Tried it a few times, then found better...

I've tried DVDXCopy, but I didn't like the notice when I put the disc in the player. Plus, I've got one copy that doesn't get past the FBI warning -- it just sits there. (Frelling Coaster!)

DVDShrink does a nice job for my own backups. I found DVDDecrypter to do a wonderful job of reading DVDs, even damaged ones. And IFOEdit is a must have tool. I spent a whole weekend learning to use these tools, and I'll never bother with DVDXCopy again.

On those episodic discs: rip to HDD with your tool of choice, and then, using IFOEdit, kill the streams of the episodes you don't want on your disc. Voila! High quality copies with no compression.

I discovered all of this because I was trying to backup a DVD before sending it back to the studios because of a bad spot on the disc. Seriously, I paid $100 for a season of a TV show, and am I expected to risk losing 4 episodes if the disc gets lost?

Dude
What Happens When I Do This
Premium
join:2000-11-20
Chicago, IL
clubs:

my thpoughts

i love dvd x copy and will never use anything else

BIGMIKE
"I do not know with what weapons World W
Premium
join:2002-06-07
Westminster, CA

Re: my thpoughts

DVDX COPY PLATINUM $150 OR ReGet Deluxe $29.95

IF you buy a copy of DVDX COPY you can make pirate DVD movies,
if you buy a copy of ReGet Deluxe you can get a free COPY of DVDX COPY and make pirate DVD movies
win it come down to it, it all pirate'see
djkosmo

join:2003-11-11
Douglasville, GA

DVD X COPY Minus Banner

Is there any patch or fix to make DVD X COPY not put that warning banner "This is a backup..."

BIGMIKE
"I do not know with what weapons World W
Premium
join:2002-06-07
Westminster, CA

Re: DVD X COPY Minus Banner

you can fix that "warning banner "This is a backup" your self if you no HOW:D
Kiwi
Premium
join:2003-05-26
USA
·Comcast
·Aristotle Internet


edit:
February 24th, @07:50PM

Re: DVD X COPY Minus Banner

I've read, so now it's a voting thing

SOoo, some people will always like click & play; that of course won't always work. Nero for one is very poor with DVD-W & excellent with CD-W. Have not run Xcopy.

The cream of the crop for DVD....Free set, well almost

DVDShrink -Free (Limited as he has been bought out, so get it quick!) Anyone remember Gladiator, that fine anti-viral progo? Bought out (Don't all the best fella's!!).

DVDdecrypter-Free

-Both work, better than a bought product.

Then there is my favourite, CopyToDVD, used with shrink. Both work well with CD-W as well.

Edit 'speeling'

Cheers
--
2.66g/533fsb Intel CPU @ 3.28g
512meg Twinmos PC3700~466 DDR @ 2.8v
ATI 9500 Pro @ 9700 Pro@1.6v

AMD ASUS A7N8X-E
2500+@3200 ATI 9500 Pro, Corsair 512LL.
djkosmo

join:2003-11-11
Douglasville, GA
Thanks I used dvd shrink last night. It worked great
Forums » 321 Studios plays hard to get


Sunday, 23-Nov 04:07:18 Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Hosting by www.nac.net - DSL,Hosting & Co-lo | feedback | contact
over 9 years online! © 1999-2008 dslreports.com.