republican-creole
Search:  

 
 
   News
newer
VOIP a 'Criminal Safe Haven'?
Justice Department, FBI begin to worry
(old news - 03:04PM Friday Mar 28 2003)
tags: legal · privacy
According to this Security Focus article, The Justice Department and the FBI are pushing regulators for broader surveillance powers to intercept Voice Over IP and any other broadband based communications techniques. Apparently law enforcement is concerned that VOIP could act as a "safe haven" for criminals and terrorists to communicate with one another. The push is sparked by the recent ability of Jeff Pulver (of Pulver.com) to win a ruling that declared his co-founded peer to peer internet telephony company free world dial-up was not subject to the same regulations that govern the telcos, bundled with his request (pdf copy) to the FCC for a "declaratory ruling" that Free World be considered "outside the commission's jurisdiction."

Related:
  1. Verizon: Public Shame Will Keep Us Honest About Privacy
  2. Wednesday Evening Links
  3. Big Brother Is Watching (And Using Deep Packet Inspection)
  4. EFF Fights Constitutionality Of Telecom Immunity
  5. Friday Evening Links
  6. Why Is NY's AG Urging ISPs To Embrace Spyware Company?
  7. NebuAD, Several ISPs Sued Over Behavioral Ads
  8. AT&T, Verizon: Privacy Advocates Extraordinaire
Forums » VOIP a 'Criminal Safe Haven'?
view: topics flat text 
Post a:
vic102482
Premium
join:2002-04-30
Upper Marlboro, MD

I didnt know it was a safe haven

Well I know now!!!!!:D

Why cant they moniter it when it leaves the internet and hits the PBX?

chrisf8657

join:2002-01-27
Glendale, AZ
clubs:

Re: I didnt know it was a safe haven

said by vic102482 See Profile:
Well I know now!!!!!:D

Why cant they moniter it when it leaves the internet and hits the PBX?
That's a good question - it has to terminate into a central office/switch over POTS at some point - I don't think phones hook up directly to an ethernet card - yet ...
--
Chris F.
Network Engineer &
Co-Webmaster/Site Designer (See profile for URL)
vic102482
Premium
join:2002-04-30
Upper Marlboro, MD
·Verizon FIOS

Re: I didnt know it was a safe haven

said by chrisf8657 See Profile:

I don't think phones hook up directly to an ethernet card - yet ...

You should call the copywright office for that one, thats a schwang idea.

How about a nic card with 2 ports. One hooks up a phone, and the other hooks up ethernet.
--
I tie a rope around my penis and jump from a tree, don't you wanna grow up to be just like me!!!!

Taget

@mindspring.com

Re: I didnt know it was a safe haven

Or better yet one connects to your ethernet card and another connects from your computer to John Ashcroft.

jtudor
Xm 60's On 6 Freak
Premium,MVM
join:2002-12-07
Morganton, NC
·AT&T Southeast

Real IP telephones do indeed connect directly to Ethernet. Look at the Cisco IP telephones. The connect to your Ethernet network, and have an Ethernet port for you to connect a computer to....Yes the computer passes through the telephone, and you only need one drop to service both.

Of course you need Cisco IP telephony equipment on site to operate the equipment, and if you are connecting to a non- Ip phone, you have to have a connection to the POTS system somewhere, but if you have a WAN setup at locations around country or the world, and you are doing internal communications over IP, those signals never hit the POTS network.
--
"Do, or Do not, there is no try!" Yoda
vic102482
Premium
join:2002-04-30
Upper Marlboro, MD
·Verizon FIOS

Re: I didnt know it was a safe haven

said by jtudor See Profile:
Real IP telephones do indeed connect directly to Ethernet.
Dammit being simple lol. We had IP phones right on our desks and I hooked some of those up myself d'oh*. (At my old job.) Its Friday thats my exscuse. lol

But we have an NT server playing the PBX on site here with the cisco IP telephony and video link software. Its pretty cool it allows us to do a multicast for a video feed so that everyone can watch TV on the computer.
--
I tie a rope around my penis and jump from a tree, don't you wanna grow up to be just like me!!!!

Sawn
U S M C
Premium
join:2003-02-24
Concord, CA

said by vic102482 See Profile:
Well I know now!!!!!:D

Why cant they moniter it when it leaves the internet and hits the PBX?
Because it never hits the PBX.
From: »www.freeworldialup.com/
Free World Dialup does not provide access to the traditional telephone networks or cellular networks. FWD members can only call other FWD members and customers of IP-based service providers who have a business relationship with FWD.
--
"The tree of liberty must be refreshed from time to time with the blood of patriots and tyrants." Thomas Jefferson
Sarge_0321

join:2002-06-27
San Diego, CA

Another way?

A dial up modem that has a software path to the Ethernet connection? Plug in the telephone to the modem? Software interlinks it?

Nevermind that crappy mic and speaker routine.

IronChefMoto
Premium
join:2001-02-08
Alpharetta, GA

Do y'all really see this as an opportunity for...

...criminals to circumvent legitimate wiretaps and eavesdropping? I'd be concerned, 'specially if terrorist cells or anti-government militia were able to use this sort of technology to get relatively unmonitorable communication.

Man -- the pitfalls of new technology. Hope they figure it out.

IronChefMorimoto
Cyron

join:2002-09-24
Charlotte, NC

edited

Re: Do y'all really see this as an opportunity for...

You could always ban all technological advances. Then criminals and terrorists would not be able to use technology for their devious purposes.
[text was edited by author 2003-03-28 15:39:59]

MrTangent

join:2001-12-28
Earth

Demonize and use buzz words to strike fear

You knew they'd mention the "terrorist" angle because nothing sells sweeping spy powers (Patriot Act, Homeland Security, etc.) like the word "terrorism"! Well placed paranoia, exploitation of fears and generalities and what-ifs sure do sell that propaganda!


--
"War Is Peace. Freedom Is Slavery. Ignorance Is Strength"
JustInit

join:2001-07-20
South Jordan, UT

Re: Demonize and use buzz words to strike fear

said by MrTangent See Profile:
You knew they'd mention the "terrorist" angle because nothing sells sweeping spy powers (Patriot Act, Homeland Security, etc.) like the word "terrorism"! Well placed paranoia, exploitation of fears and generalities and what-ifs sure do sell that propaganda!
Sure there may be some of what you mention going on with this but at the same time how many posts have you read that wave a warning flag regarding firewalls and PC security on this very forum?

The context is different but the concept is very much the same. Raise a warning to play on peoples fears or better yet, raise the warning to create the fear.

Most who frequent this forum would never even consider connecting to the Internet without running a firewall of some kind to "protect" them from the unseen cyber-assailant.

Furthermore there is a tendency to view any who don't recognize the risk of getting hacked as ignorant and even deserving of being hacked.

I recognize that the two scenarios are not exactly the same but, as I said, the concept is very much the same.

LoonRadio
Tranquility Base
Premium
join:2003-02-13
Erewhon
·Verizon Online DSL

Internet's Barbary Coast

Okay, we've seen attempts to criminalize P2P and firewalls, and now this? Focussing immediately on possible illegal usage at this point seems premature and alarmist. Let the technology develop and see how it is really used before characterizing its users as criminals.

As for Pulver's request for exemption, that would set a terrible precedent. No one company should have a wide open field to itself.
--
Klaatu, Barada... Necktie!

Krytor
Reminiscing The Future
Premium
join:2001-07-07
Indianapolis, IN
·AT&T U-Verse


edited

Use good encryption?

They forgot or chose to ignore good encryption?

Modified Devo "whip it" lyrics... *cough*

Encrypt that stream*
give the feds the slip
load up your app
send your message out

When a problem comes along
you must encrypt it
before the file sits out too long
you must encrypt it
when something's going wrong
you must encrypt it

Now encrypt it
into files
back it up
please wait
go connect
send it out
try to detect it
it's not too late
to encrypt it
encrypt it good

When a good idea comes around
you must encrypt it
you will never keep it safe
unless you encrypt it
no one gets their way
until they encrypt it

I say encrypt it
encrypt it good

* - data stream
edit: typo
[text was edited by author 2003-03-28 16:31:37]

LoonRadio
Tranquility Base
Premium
join:2003-02-13
Erewhon

Re: Use good encryption?

You deserve some sort of prize for that.
--
Klaatu, Barada... Necktie!

David
Last man standing
Premium,VIP
join:2002-05-30
Granite City, IL
clubs:
I will give that a thumbs up.....
jdir

join:2001-05-04
Santa Clara, CA

VOIP over VPN

yep - VOIP over VPN will make wire tapping totally useless.
ross

join:2000-08-16
·Digizip

Seems to be the measure of freedom these days...

If there is any possibility that the government can't access the private communications of its' citizens at will, the empowering technology and its users are labeled terrorist, or criminal, with no evidence of such activity required.

This growing fear of its' own citizens by government is a projection of the governments' own dishonesty, it is not based on a rational assessment of the loyalty or trustworthiness of the governed.

These days, our government abhors the freedoms which are our birthright.
Gorn

join:2002-09-16
Campbell, CA

Re: Seems to be the measure of freedom these days.


Now now... freedom isn't a right, it's a privilege!

(kidding)
Cyron

join:2002-09-24
Charlotte, NC

Ban Sign Language

I think our government should ban Sign Language. Afterall, what's the point of planting a bug in someone's house/car/phone, if they can use sign language to defeat our technology.

It's those damn deaf people that invented something a terrorist might be able to use against everyone.
flomokas
Premium
join:2003-01-06
Moberly, MO

Combating Terrorism

Back in the 80's, I arrived at my first military assignment shortly after local Red Army members blew up some of equipment. Luckily, no one was hurt, except some careers went into the toilet. For a couple months guard duty became a serious matter, until higher ups could put into place major security.

What did this security consist of? A few pens of geese placed near the fence line. From my observations, geese do basically the 3 Ss: (1)sleep, (2)sham and (3)sh*t. Not always in that order. The real joke was that most the local Germans knew the attack was coming shortly before hand.

Unless people can get "free" equipment like Vonage provides, I don't see this really taking off due to the cost of the Cisco phone.

sporkme
drop the crantini and move it, sister
Premium,MVM
join:2000-07-01
Budd Lake, NJ
·Optimum Online

More to ban...

We should probably also be frightened of AIM, ICQ, IRC, steganography, IP phones set to talk directly to each other, and of course MSN Messenger. And don't forget all the video conferencing products. We should also probably get a jump on banning all cryptography as well. And winpopup.

Then when that's done, only the criminals will be able to use that stuff.

These folks are very narrow-minded and incapable of thinking things through. There are plenty of ways for criminals to communicate that are not easily "tapped". There always will be.

Maybe it's all being pushed by the telcos, who figure pushing these requirements onto the likes of Net2Phone and Vonage will run them out of business.

richk_1957
If ..Then..Else
Premium
join:2001-04-11
Minas Tirith

Re: More to ban...

You forgot something...
FAX

In the name of the fight against terrorism, domestic security - whatever you want to call it, 1984 is approaching fast
And if anyone complains they will say that this is done only if there is suspected activity.
Who makes that definition?

And someone at the top will break sometime and use the information for personal use. It's just a matter of time.

bear73
Metnav... Fly The Unfriendly Skies
Premium
join:2001-06-09
Grand Forks Afb, ND
·Midcontinent Commu..

This isn't much different then the crazy gun-control laws (I can feel the flames already). The gun control laws have only slowed the folks buying guns honestly and legally. The criminals still can get their stuff through the black market. The lawmakers are just scared and think that more controls is the answer.

To the carpenter, every problem looks like a nail and he'll just hit it with his hammer.
--
If ya gotta go, Go with a SMILE!
Forums » VOIP a 'Criminal Safe Haven'?


Sunday, 23-Nov 04:05:29 Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Hosting by www.nac.net - DSL,Hosting & Co-lo | feedback | contact
over 9 years online! © 1999-2008 dslreports.com.